Chatham Artillery punch

Lore & Background

One legend has it that George Washington was presented the punch when he arrived at Chatham Artillery in 1792, and he gave the regiment two cannons. A more plausible story was reported in an 1885 article for the Augusta Chronicle, stating that the punch was created in the 1850s when the Republican Blues returned from a drill in Macon and were welcomed back by Sergeant A. B. Luce and the Chatham Artillery. The punch was said to have been created by adding a quart of brandy, whiskey, and rum along with Champagne, lemon, and sugar to a horse bucket containing crushed ice; every man who drank it was inebriated.

In 1870, a group of Southern journalists held a convention in Savannah and were served the punch on a riverboat cruise. They became inebriated and reported their encounter with the drink, propelling it to national fame. A later tale claimed President Chester Arthur was overcome by it, but no established record confirms this. An unsubstantiated story also suggests Admiral George Dewey got drunk from the punch in 1900, with a recipe named after him.

Reader's Guide

Chatham Artillery punch is significant as a regional American cocktail with a storied history tied to Savannah, Georgia, and its military heritage. The drink gained national attention after a 1870 convention of Southern journalists became inebriated on a riverboat cruise and wrote about it. Its potency was legendary, besting figures such as President Chester Arthur and Admiral George Dewey. The drink was later revised to become less potent; a 1907 recipe noted that 'experience has taught the rising generation to modify the receipt of their forefathers to conform to the weaker constitutions of their progeny.' After Prohibition ended in the late 1930s, the cocktail grew in popularity again, with new recipes sometimes including liquors like scotch and gin and even excluding Champagne. The drink's legacy continues in modern variations, such as Champagne punch, and it was referenced in the 1997 film adaptation of Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil. Its preparation traditionally involves muddling lemon peels with sugar, adding lemon juice, and combining with crushed ice and spirits.

Did You Know?

• One legend claims George Washington was given the punch in 1792 and responded by giving the Chatham Artillery two cannons.
• An 1885 article reported the punch was created in the 1850s by adding spirits to a horse bucket of crushed ice.
• President Chester Arthur was said to have been bested by the drink.

Origins Wrapped in Legend

The true creator and original recipe of Chatham Artillery punch remain shrouded in mystery, giving the drink an air of romantic uncertainty that has only deepened its allure. One popular tale claims that George Washington himself was served the punch upon visiting the Chatham Artillery regiment in 1792, and in gratitude presented the unit with two cannons. A more grounded account surfaced in an 1885 Augusta Chronicle article, placing the drink's birth in the 1850s. According to that report, the Republican Blues came home from a drill in Macon and were greeted by Sergeant A. B. Luce and fellow Chatham Artillery members with a bucket of crushed ice into which a quart each of brandy, whiskey, and rum was poured, followed by Champagne, lemon, and sugar. The result was so potent that every man who tasted it was left thoroughly inebriated. A separate Civil War legend holds that Savannah residents fed General Sherman so much of the punch during his march that he chose to spare the city from destruction.

A Drink That Felled the Powerful

The punch's reputation as a formidable adversary spread far beyond Savannah's borders, largely thanks to a string of high-profile encounters that made national headlines. In 1870, a gathering of Southern journalists met in Savannah and were treated to the punch aboard a riverboat cruise. The group became so thoroughly inebriated that they wrote up their disoriented experience for publication, even attempting to guess the drink's true contents. That coverage propelled Chatham Artillery punch into the national consciousness. The list of distinguished victims grew over the decades: President Chester Arthur was reportedly bested by a serving, and in 1900 Admiral George Dewey, the celebrated hero of the 1898 Battle of Manila Bay, was similarly overcome after imbibing the mixture. His encounter was significant enough that a subsequent recipe was named in his honor. These stories reinforced the punch's identity as a drink of genuine danger, one that could humble even the most prominent figures of the era and cemented its place in American cocktail lore as something more than mere refreshment.

A Recipe That Learned to Temper Itself

Over the decades, Chatham Artillery punch underwent a slow but noticeable softening, a concession to changing palates and weaker constitutions. A 1907 recipe captured the shift in characteristically wry language, noting that experience had taught the rising generation to modify the receipt of their forefathers to conform to the weaker constitutions of their progeny. The drink's trajectory was further shaped by Prohibition, which effectively halted its public presence for a generation. When the ban lifted in the late 1930s, the cocktail re-emerged with renewed popularity, though the recipes had drifted considerably. A 1939 New York Sun publication offered a version that was substantially different from earlier iterations, sometimes incorporating scotch and gin and occasionally dropping Champagne altogether. Ingredient availability also drove change: Santa Cruz rum gained favor in the post-Prohibition era, though a heavy dark rum is considered closer to what the original likely used, and the once-common Catawba wine, now hard to source, is typically replaced with a white wine or Champagne.

From Muddled Peels to Modern Twists

Preparing Chatham Artillery punch begins with a tactile, almost ritualistic step: lemon peels are muddled with sugar to draw out their fragrant oils, then combined with lemon juice and strained before being added to a large bowl of crushed ice. Into that icy base go the three spirits—brandy, rum, and whiskey—followed by Champagne. While not considered traditional, candied cherries and their jar juice are frequently stirred in, and modern recipes sometimes introduce gin as an additional layer. The drink has also spawned gentler offshoots for social occasions. Champagne punch, a less potent cousin, blends Curaçao or Cointreau, a few dashes of bitters, fresh strawberries, lemon, simple syrup, brandy, and Champagne, making it a favorite at wedding receptions and Christmas parties. The punch's spirit lives on in similar regional drinks like regent's punch along the East Coast and Fish house punch in the Northeast. In the 1997 film adaptation of Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil, the drink is captured in a single evocative line: three parts fruit, seven parts liquor, whatever's available on both counts.

Gallery