Johnny Cash Codexery

American III: Solitary Man

Third album in Cash's American series, released in 2000.

American III: Solitary Man, Johnny Cash's sixty-sixth studio album, came out on October 17, 2000, through American Recordings. It stands as the third installment in his American series and the second-to-last studio album released while he was alive.

Cash's health took a turn for the worse between American II: Unchained and this album. He dealt with several illnesses and ended up hospitalized for pneumonia, which forced him to cut back on touring. The album reflects his response to that struggle, most clearly in his takes on Tom Petty's "I Won't Back Down" and U2's "One." Listeners can hear changes in Cash's voice caused by his health issues, especially compared to his earlier records. Writer Graeme Thomson described Solitary Man as an act of emotional preservation.

Three songs on the album had been recorded by Cash before. "Field of Diamonds" originally appeared with Waylon Jennings on their 1986 album Heroes. "Country Trash" first showed up on Cash's 1973 record Any Old Wind That Blows. "I'm Leavin' Now" was previously on his 1985 album Rainbow.

Critics mostly gave the album positive reviews. On Metacritic, it scored an 80 out of 100 from 15 reviews, meaning "generally favorable reviews." David Browne of Entertainment Weekly gave it an A, noting that while Cash's voice rarely sounded darker, producer Rick Rubin framed it with harmonies and church organs to create an "austere but welcoming" album. Sonicnet praised Cash's ability to strip away previous associations from songs and reveal their core. Billboard said the album might lack the immediate impact of its predecessors but was still a masterpiece. Splendid remarked that while the covers draw attention, Cash's own material steals the show. Jim DeRogatis of the Chicago Sun-Times called it arguably the strongest of the American series, highlighting Cash's rendition of Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds' "The Mercy Seat" as the best performance and most inspired cover choice.

Rolling Stone gave a mixed review, criticizing Rick Rubin's production as too timid, with sparse arrangements of guitar, fiddle, and accordion that felt like a "severe meal" one is forced to consider tasteful. The A.V. Club compared it to Neil Young's Silver and Gold, calling it a thematically empty placeholder, unlike the devotion and doubt of American Recordings.

Quick Facts

Artist
Johnny Cash
Released
October 17, 2000
Recorded
2000
Genre
Country
Length
42:15
Label
American
Producer
Rick Rubin; John Carter Cash

Facts from the source article.

Track listing

No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1I Won't Back Down (with Tom Petty)Tom Petty, Jeff Lynne2:09
2Solitary ManNeil Diamond2:25
3That Lucky Old Sun (Just Rolls Around Heaven All Day)Haven Gillespie, Beasley Smith2:35
4OneBono, Adam Clayton, The Edge, Larry Mullen3:53
5NobodyBert Williams3:14
6I See a Darkness (with Will Oldham)Will Oldham3:42
7The Mercy SeatNick Cave, Mick Harvey4:35
8Would You Lay with Me (In a Field of Stone)David Allan Coe2:41
9Field of DiamondsJohnny Cash, Jack Wesley Routh3:15
10Before My TimeCash2:55
11Country TrashCash1:47
12Mary of the Wild MoorDennis Turner2:32
13I'm Leavin' Now (with Merle Haggard)Cash3:07
14Wayfaring StrangerTraditional3:19
Total length42:15

Track listing from the source article.

Did You Know?

More in Albums & EPs

Elsewhere in Johnny Cash

Spotted an error? Know more?

Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced

Comments

Loading…
Open in the interactive codex →