2007 AS Roma–Manchester United F.C. conflict

Lore & Background

Before the match, riot police positioned themselves only on the Manchester United side of the perspex barrier. After Roma scored, their fans allegedly threw missiles over the barrier into Manchester United fans. Reports claim that a section of Manchester United fans pushed past stewards, prompting riot police to move in to control the United crowd. Manchester United accused the Italian police of handing out indiscriminate beatings, and many supporters claimed the police response was disproportionate. Eleven Manchester United supporters and two Roma supporters were taken to hospital. UEFA launched an investigation, and Home Office Minister Vernon Coaker said answers were needed regarding possible police brutality. Amnesty International backed calls for an inquiry. Achille Serra, head of Rome Police, called the action a justified response, and Italian Football Federation President Giancarlo Abete defended the police. Psychologist Clifford Stott criticized the Italian police, suggesting Italian fans may have provoked police action against English fans.

Reader's Guide

The 2007 AS Roma–Manchester United conflict is significant as a flashpoint in football hooliganism and police conduct. The incident highlighted tensions between English and Italian fan cultures and the role of riot police in stadium security. The controversy centered on whether police used excessive force against Manchester United supporters, with accusations of indiscriminate beatings. The event prompted investigations by UEFA and calls from Amnesty International for an inquiry. In the return leg at Old Trafford, police used batons, horses, and dogs against Roma fans after bottle-throwing, leading to 21 arrests. The conflict also spurred a personal apology from Roma captain Francesco Totti to a female United fan. The fines imposed by UEFA—CHF 75,000 on Roma and CHF 35,500 on Manchester United—reflected the governing body's assessment of responsibility. The incident remains a reference point for debates on policing at football matches and the treatment of traveling supporters.

Did You Know?

• Roma were fined CHF 75,000 and Manchester United were fined CHF 35,500 by UEFA.
• Roma captain Francesco Totti made a personal video apology to a female United fan caught in the clash.
• Psychologist Clifford Stott suggested Italian fans may have used violence against English fans to provoke police action.