Attempt
A crime of intent and substantial step toward completion.
Last updated
Attempt is an inchoate crime, meaning it is an incomplete offense that criminalizes conduct falling short of the completed act. It arises when a person possesses the specific intent to commit a crime and takes a substantial step toward its completion, but the intended crime does not occur due to circumstances beyond the actor’s control. The offense requires two core elements: a guilty mind (mens rea) and a guilty act (actus reus). The actus reus of an attempt is defined by conduct that goes beyond mere planning or preparation and is sufficiently proximate to the full offense.
England and Wales
Distinguishing preparatory acts from those that constitute an attempt is a question of fact for a jury, guided by legal instructions. Early common law did not punish attempts; the crime was first recognized in the 1784 case of Rex v. Scofield. In English law, the Criminal Attempts Act 1981 defines the actus reus as an act that is “more than merely preparatory” to the commission of the offense, a standard that replaced the earlier common law “last step” or “point of no return” test.
This allows liability to attach slightly earlier in the sequence of actions, though the precise meaning of “more than merely preparatory” remains subject to judicial discretion, as seen in cases like R v Geddes, where a defendant’s acts were deemed insufficient. In the United States, tests for the actus reus vary, generally falling into two categories: those focusing on how much remains to be done, and those considering what has already occurred.
United States
New York law, for example, requires conduct that “tends to effect the commission of such crime,” applying either a res ipsa loquitur standard (where the action itself reveals criminal intent) or a dangerous proximity test, formulated by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes in Commonwealth v. Peaslee. Punishment for attempt is often less severe than for the completed crime, and voluntary abandonment may serve as a defense, depending on its timing and voluntariness.
Quick Facts
- Field
- Criminal law
- Defense possible
- Voluntary abandonment may constitute a defense
Facts from the source article.
Frequently Asked Questions
What exactly is Attempt in criminal law?
Attempt is an inchoate offense that criminalizes the pairing of a specific criminal purpose with a meaningful act moving toward that goal, even though the target crime never actually materializes for reasons outside the actor's control.
What two elements must be present to charge Attempt?
Prosecutors must prove both a direct, specific intent to carry out the underlying offense and physical conduct that goes beyond mere planning or preparation—a substantial step toward execution.
How does Attempt compare in severity to the completed crime?
It is generally treated as an offense of equal or lesser gravity than the full target crime, reflecting the fact that the harmful result was never realized.
Is there a way to escape an Attempt charge?
Yes—voluntary abandonment, where the actor of their own free will renounces the criminal plan before the crime is completed, can serve as a valid defense.
More in Legal Systems & Concepts
Sources
Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.
- Wikipedia: Attempt (CC BY-SA 4.0).
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced
