Great man theory
History as the biography of great men
The great man theory holds that individual heroes, through their unique attributes, decisively shape history.[1][2] Thomas Carlyle stated that "The History of the world is but the Biography of great men"[1] The theory was most fashionable among professional historians in the 19th century.[3]
Quick Facts
- Field
- Historiography
- Primary proponent
- Thomas Carlyle
- Contrasted with
- People's history, historical materialism
Facts from the source article.
What happened
Thomas Carlyle, in his 1840 work Heroes and Hero-Worship, analyzed six types of heroes: divinity, prophet, poet, priest, man of letters, and king.[1] Carlyle argued that studying great men was "profitable" to uncovering one's own true nature.[4] Sidney Hook noted that a common misinterpretation is that all other factors are inconsequential, whereas Carlyle claimed great men are the decisive factor.[2] Frederick Adams Woods supported the theory by investigating 386 rulers in Western Europe from the 12th century to the French Revolution.[5]
The theory rests on assumptions that great leaders are born with certain traits and that great need must arise for those traits to emerge.[6] Herbert Spencer criticized the theory as unscientific, believing great men are products of their social environment.[7] William James defended Carlyle in his 1880 lecture, arguing that genetic anomalies in great men's brains introduce original influences.[8][9] Leo Tolstoy criticized great-man theories in War and Peace, calling great individuals "history's slaves".[10]
Hegel, in his Philosophy of History, described world-historical individuals as those whose personal aims align with the World-Spirit's will, stating they "are great historical men—whose own particular aims involve those large issues which are the will of the World-Spirit."[11]
What the cited sources add
Mark Twain suggested in his essay "The United States of Lyncherdom" that moral cowardice is the commanding feature of 9,999 men in 10,000.[12] Twain wrote that no revolt against oppression has ever been begun but by the one daring man in the 10,000.[13][12] William Fielding Ogburn noted in 1926 that Great Men history was being challenged by newer interpretations focusing on wider social forces.[14] Ogburn saw Great Men as inevitable products of productive cultures.[14]
References
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Thomas Carlyle, "The Hero as Divinity" in: Heroes and Hero-Worship (1840).; Hirsch, E.D. The New Dictionary of Cultural Literacy (Third Edition), Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, 2002. (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Sidney Hook (1955) The Hero in History, Boston: Beacon Press, p. 14 (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: As to Hegel and Nietzsche: Edelstein, Alan (1996) Everybody is Sitting on the Curb: How and why America's Heroes Disappeared. Greenwood.; As to Kierkegaard: Evjen, John Oluf (1938). The Life of J. H. W. Stuckenberg: Theologian, Philosopher, Sociologist, Friend of Humanity. Luther Free Church Publi; As to Spengler, Nietzsche, Bloy and Weber: Saul, John Ralston (2012). The Doubter's Companion: A Dictionary of Aggressive Common Sense. New York: Simon & Schust (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Carlyle, Thomas. On Heroes, Hero-Worship and the Heroic in History , Fredrick A. Stokes & Brother, New York, 1888. p. 2. (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Woods, F. A. (1913). The Influence of Monarchs: Steps in a New Science of History. New York City: Macmillan. (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: "What is the Great Man Theory?", Villanova University, 8 January 2015 (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Segal, Robert A. Hero Myths, Wiley-Blackwell, 2000, p. 3. (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: James, William (1880), "Great Men, Great Thoughts, and the Environment"; "William James: Great Men, Great Thoughts, and the Environment", brocku.ca (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: "William James: Great Men, Great Thoughts, and the Environment", brocku.ca (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Tolstoy, L. (2010) [1st pub. 1869]. Translated by Maude, Louise, and Maude, Aylmer. War and Peace. Bk. IX, ch. 1. Oxford: Oxford University Press. (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Hegel, G. W. F. [1837]. Philosophy of History. trans. J. Sibree (New York: Dover, 1956), 30. (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Twain, Mark (1901, pub. 1923). "The United States of Lyncherdom" – via Wikisource. (we also read that source) en.wikipedia.org
- Twain, Mark (1901, pub. 1923). "The United States of Lyncherdom" – via Wikisource.. facts only, no text reused. en.wikisource.org
- Wikipedia, "Great man theory" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Ogburn, "The Great Man versus Social Forces", Social Forces, Dec 1926, p. 225–231; Hook, S. (1943). The Hero in History. A Study in Limitation and Possibility. Boston, Massachusetts: Beacon Press. p. 116 (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
Each numbered sentence above was checked against the source it cites before publication. Sentences citing Wikipedia adapt text from the English Wikipedia article Great man theory (contributors), used under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is available under the same licence. Other sources were used for facts only; no text or images are copied from them.
More in Historiography & Methods
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced