Eminem Codexery

Eight Mile Style v New Zealand National Party

Landmark New Zealand copyright case over political ad sound-alike.

Eight Mile Style v New Zealand National Party

Sodacan · via Wikipedia: Eight Mile Style v New Zealand National Party · CC BY-SA 3.0

Eight Mile Style v New Zealand National Party [2017] NZHC 2603 was a High Court of New Zealand ruling that the National Party breached copyright by using a sound-alike version of Eminem's song "Lose Yourself" in a 2014 election campaign ad. Eminem's publishers, Eight Mile Style and Martin Affiliated, launched a lawsuit in Wellington on 16 September 2016, claiming the party, its ad agency, and others involved in creating and licensing the track had infringed copyright by using an instrumental version without permission.

Campaign manager Steven Joyce said the use was "pretty legal," arguing the track had been bought from an Australian music library. The publishers countered that they had never allowed the song in a political ad. The trial ran from 1 to 12 May 2017, with Justice Helen Cull reserving her decision. On 25 October, the High Court found the National Party and co-defendants liable for copyright breach and ordered them to pay $600,000 plus interest.

The National Party appealed, arguing no breach occurred and that damages were too high. Eight Mile Style and Martin Affiliated cross-appealed, seeking higher damages. The Court of Appeal upheld the breach finding but reduced damages to $225,000. Eight Mile Style then sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in May 2019, but the application was dismissed, and they were ordered to pay $4,500 in costs.

Eight Mile Style spokesman Joel Martin said the company was happy with the result after a "distasteful" trial. National Party president Peter Goodfellow expressed disappointment and said the party would pursue legal action against Labrador and Beatbox, who supplied the music. Eminem told Variety he was not consulted about the case but would donate any money he received to Hurricane Harvey relief. Former APRA director Mike Chunn said sound-alike recordings are common in advertising and called the ruling unfair.

Quick Facts

Court
High Court of New Zealand at Wellington
Date decided
25 October 2017
Judges
Helen Cull
Number of judges
1
Keywords
Copyright Act 1994

Facts from the source article.

More in People

Elsewhere in Eminem

Spotted an error? Know more?

Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced

Comments

Loading…
Open in the interactive codex →