Animal, Vegetable, Mineral?

Lore & Background

The show was modelled on the American program What in the World? developed by Froelich Rainey. The first episode was hosted by Lionel Hale and produced by Paul Johnstone. Hale soon stepped down after being challenged by Thomas Bodkin about the age of an object, and was replaced by archaeologist Glyn Daniel, who served as chairman and scorer for the next seven years. The most frequent panelist was Sir Mortimer Wheeler, who was voted TV personality of the year in 1954, becoming archaeology's first media star; Daniel won the award the following year.

The artefacts for each episode were chosen by the production team, with Sir David Attenborough serving as a producer rather than the sole chooser or camera director. Inauthentic items were occasionally included, such as a stone axe made by the forger 'Flint Jack' or fake Crown Derby ware. On one occasion, Sir Julian Huxley failed to identify a modern mock-up of a stuffed great auk as a fake, and on another he lost a £1 bet after failing to recognize the egg of the African giant snail. The presenter sometimes tried to fool the panel with corroded modern artefacts like parts of a pram or a bicycle.

Controversies included Wheeler often 'cheating' by investigating beforehand which objects had been removed, though he once stormed off set when a junior producer offered to show him planned items. In 1957, an episode featuring human volunteers to identify ethnic origins was disrupted by anthropologist Margaret Mead, who was not invited again. Glyn Daniel once presented while suffering from influenza and said on air that 'there are a few million people I would like to kill – mostly viewers'; Attenborough later explained Daniel had been drunk. Leigh Ashton, Director of the Victoria and Albert Museum, also appeared drunk and fell asleep after incorrectly stating the first three objects were fakes.

Reader's Guide

Animal, Vegetable, Mineral? was a pioneering BBC television panel show that ran from 1952 to 1959, bringing archaeology and museum artefacts into the public eye. It was modelled on an American show and featured experts such as Sir Mortimer Wheeler and Glyn Daniel, who became media personalities. The show is credited with increasing museum attendance and library use in Britain during the 1950s, and its format influenced later BBC archaeology programs like Buried Treasure and Chronicle. The program occasionally included inauthentic items and faced controversies, including panelists cheating or appearing intoxicated. Only four episodes exist in the BBC archives, three of which are available on BBC iPlayer. The show's legacy includes parodies in comedy series such as Not Only...But Also and The Armstrong & Miller Show, and a one-off revival at University College London in September 2011.

Did You Know?

• The show was modelled on an American TV show called What in the World? developed by Froelich Rainey.
• Only three episodes are known to survive in the BBC's archives, and they are not all available on BBC iPlayer.

Origins and the Art of the Panel

The BBC's Animal, Vegetable, Mineral? took to the airwaves on 23 October 1952 and ran until 18 March 1959, giving British viewers a weekly dose of scholarly debate over curious objects. The format drew inspiration from an American programme called What in the World?, developed by Froelich Rainey, and transplanted the concept of expert identification into a distinctly British setting. Each episode gathered a panel of archaeologists, art historians, and natural-history specialists who were challenged to identify artefacts drawn from museums across Britain and the world, as well as from university collections. The very first broadcast was chaired by Lionel Hale and produced by Paul Johnstone, but Hale's tenure was short-lived; after a panelist named Thomas Bodkin publicly questioned him on the age of an object on screen, Hale stepped aside. In his place came the archaeologist Glyn Daniel, who would steer the show as chairman and scorer for the following seven years. The critic C.A. Lejeune, writing in 1953, captured the programme's appeal by describing it as possessing "a sound, full-bodied, vintage flavour," a phrase that neatly summed up the blend of erudition and entertainment the show delivered.

Scandals, Snubs, and Scholarly Spats

The show's reputation for intellectual rigour was frequently tested by the very personalities it showcased. Sir Mortimer Wheeler, the most regular panelist, was known to prepare for episodes by tracking which objects had been removed from their display cases and cross-referencing museum catalogues in advance. Yet when a junior producer once offered to reveal the upcoming items to him before filming, Wheeler stormed off the set in indignation. In 1957, an episode asked the panel to identify the ethnic origins of human volunteers, a premise that prompted the anthropologist Margaret Mead to repeatedly interrupt, insisting that representatives of every group could simply be found at New York's Grand Central Station. She was never invited back. Glyn Daniel's on-air conduct also drew attention: during a discussion of poisoned arrows from the Sarawak State Museum, he declared on air that there were "a few million people I would like to kill – mostly viewers." Attenborough later revealed in his autobiography that Daniel had been drunk that day. Meanwhile, Leigh Ashton, director of the Victoria and Albert Museum, appeared inebriated on another occasion and fell asleep after wrongly dismissing the first three objects as fakes.

Shaping a Nation's Love of the Past

Animal, Vegetable, Mineral? is widely credited with igniting a postwar enthusiasm for archaeology across Britain. In the 1950s, the programme helped drive a noticeable rise in museum attendance and library use, and the BBC's Director-General Sir Ian Jacob reportedly observed that the two most popular subjects on television appeared to be archaeology and show-jumping. The show also proved academically useful: on several occasions, museums revised their own identifications of objects after the panel or the viewing public offered new information. Its influence extended well beyond the studio. It served as a direct forerunner to later BBC archaeology programmes such as Buried Treasure and Chronicle. The format became a staple of British comedy, with sketches in Not Only...But Also, At Last the 1948 Show, Do Not Adjust Your Set, and The Complete and Utter History of Britain all parodying experts misidentifying a "mystery object." Even into the 21st century, the show's simple premise was still being riffed on, as when The Armstrong & Miller Show parodied it with a fictional black-and-white programme called "How many hats?" In September 2011, University College London staged a one-off revival featuring experts in Scandinavian Studies, Physics, Philosophy, and Zoology, hosted by Joe Flatman.

Behind the Camera and the Curious Fakes

The production side of the show was as distinctive as its on-screen format. Sir David Attenborough was responsible for selecting each episode's artefact and also served as camera director. On the 1956 Christmas special, the roles were reversed: Glyn Daniel and Sir Mortimer Wheeler chose the items, and it was Attenborough and other production staff who had to examine them. The show was not above a touch of mischief. Inauthentic objects were deliberately slipped into the lineup, including a stone axe crafted by the forger known as "Flint Jack" and pieces of fake Crown Derby ware. Sir Julian Huxley was unable to spot a modern mock-up of a stuffed great auk as a forgery, and on another occasion he lost a one-pound bet after failing to recognise the egg of the African giant snail. The presenter would sometimes try to trip up the panel with a corroded piece of modern junk, such as a part of a pram or a bicycle. The series was bookended by the prelude to Bach's Partita No. 3 in E major. Only four episodes survive in the BBC's archives; three are available on iPlayer, while the fourth is silent, its audio track having been lost.

Gallery