American Old West Gunfights Codexery

Hickok–Tutt shootout

A quick-draw duel in Springfield, Missouri, on July 21, 1865.

Last updated

On July 21, 1865, Wild Bill Hickok and gambler Davis Tutt faced off in a public square in Springfield, Missouri. This shootout stands as a rare real-life example of a quick-draw duel between two men, the kind later romanticized in Western fiction and films like High Noon. A Harper's Magazine article from 1867 first told the story, turning Hickok into a famous folk hero.

The card game

The conflict escalated during a poker game at the Lyon House Hotel. Hickok was playing against several local gamblers while Tutt stood nearby, loaning money and coaching them on how to beat Hickok. The stakes were high, and Hickok had won about $200 of what was essentially Tutt's money.

Irritated, Tutt reminded Hickok of a $40 debt from a past horse trade. Hickok paid the sum, but Tutt then claimed an additional $35 from a past poker game. Hickok said he owed only $25 and had a memorandum in his pocket.

Encouraged by armed associates, Tutt grabbed Hickok's Waltham repeater gold pocket watch from the table, announcing he would keep it as collateral until Hickok paid the full $35. Hickok, outnumbered and outgunned, quietly demanded the watch back. Tutt replied with an ugly grin and left with the watch.

Failed negotiations

The next morning, Tutt showed up in the town square around ten o'clock, Hickok's watch dangling conspicuously from his pocket. News of the display traveled fast, reaching Hickok within sixty minutes. Witnesses Eli Armstrong, John Orr, and Oliver Scott later testified that Hickok confronted Tutt to negotiate the watch's return. Tutt raised his price to forty-five dollars.

Armstrong urged Tutt to settle for the original thirty-five and work out the difference later, but Hickok held firm that he only owed twenty-five. Tutt dangled the watch in front of Hickok and refused to take less than forty-five. Both men claimed they wanted to avoid a fight and shared a drink. Tutt soon departed, only to return to the square with the watch still on display.

The shootout

Just before six in the evening, Hickok walked into the square from the south, holding his Colt Navy. Onlookers quickly fled into nearby buildings for cover, leaving Tutt alone at the northwest corner. Hickok stopped about seventy-five yards away, faced Tutt, and said, "Dave, here I am." He cocked his pistol, returned it to his holster, and warned, "Don't you come across here with that watch." Tutt stayed silent, his hand resting on his own gun.

Both men turned sideways, adopting the dueling stance. After a brief pause, Tutt went for his pistol. Hickok drew, steadying the barrel on his opposite forearm.

They each fired one shot almost simultaneously. Tutt’s shot missed; Hickok’s bullet hit Tutt in the left side between his fifth and seventh ribs. Tutt cried out, "Boys, I'm killed," stumbled onto the courthouse porch, then back into the street, where he fell and died.

Trial and aftermath

The next day, a warrant was issued for Hickok's arrest, and two days later he was arrested. Bail was initially denied, as is common in murder cases. Hickok eventually posted a $2,000 bail on the same day after the magistrate reduced the charge from murder to manslaughter. Hickok was arrested under the name William Haycocke for the manslaughter of David Tutt.

During the trial, the names were amended to J. B. Hickok and Davis Tutt/Little Dave. The manslaughter trial began on August 3, 1865, and lasted three days. Twenty-two witnesses from the square testified. Hickok's lawyer was Colonel John S. Phelps, former Union military Governor of Arkansas.

The prosecution was led by Major Robert W. Fyan; the judge was Sempronius H. Boyd. Trial transcripts have been lost, but newspaper reports indicate Hickok claimed self-defense. The most disputed fact was who fired first. Four witnesses watched the fight: two claimed both men fired but could not tell who drew first; one saw only Hickok draw; another said Tutt did not fire but admitted noticing Tutt's gun had a discharged chamber.

Other witnesses heard only one shot. Hickok's claim of self-defense was technically invalid under state law pertaining to mutual combat, but the jury decided he was justified. As Tutt initiated the fight by taking the watch and was the first to display overt aggression, and two witnesses indicated Tutt reached for his pistol first, the unwritten law dictated Hickok was justified, and he was absolved of guilt.

Did You Know?

More in American Old West Gunfights

Sources

Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.

Spotted an error? Know more?

Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced

Comments

Loading…
Open in the interactive codex →