Blackwell gunfight
Posse kills one outlaw, wounds another near Blackwell.
Last updated
Near Blackwell, Oklahoma, on the morning of December 4, 1896, a posse of lawmen cornered two bandits at their hideout. A long shootout ended with Deputy Alfred O. Lund killing Dick Ainsley and wounding Ben Cravens, who was then captured.
Background
Ben Cravens and Dick Ainsley were petty thieves and cattle rustlers, with Ainsley also known as a gunman who went by the names "Buck" McGregg or "Diamond Dick," the latter because he had a diamond ring and three fingers shot away in a gunfight with Lincoln County policemen. On November 27, 1896, they rode into Blackwell to buy supplies and case the bank for a robbery, then left for a one-room shack next to a dry wooded ravine called Lost Creek, about three and a half miles northwest of town.
Lacking a well, Cravens asked neighbor Bert Benjamin for water, and during their talk Cravens asked about the bank's interior, revealing his intentions. Benjamin replied casually and the next day reported the conversation to sheriff's deputy J. R. Cox. Cox, believing the pair responsible for a store robbery in Hewins, Kansas, told Benjamin to report back if he saw them again. On December 3, after Benjamin sighted the outlaws again, Cox raised a posse of six men: himself, Alfred O. Lund, Bill Sherr, John Hunter, Jay McClain, and Richard Clarke.
Lund, a livery stable owner who had lost elections for city marshal and town constable, saw the opportunity to enter law enforcement without being elected.
Gunfight
At sunrise, Dick Ainsley stepped outside the shack with a Winchester rifle, looked around, leaned the rifle against the shack, and began washing his hands. Ben Cravens then appeared at the front of the cabin, also carrying a rifle. Deputy Cox stood from his hiding place and shouted for them to surrender, but the outlaws raised their weapons and opened fire. After the first shots, Bert Benjamin fired both barrels of his shotgun and then fled home, leaving Alfred Lund alone at his position in front of the shack.
Lund had a good vantage point and saw that the rest of the posse, armed mainly with shotguns, lacked the range to be effective. Cravens was the first wounded: a rifle bullet broke his collarbone as he ran for the corner of the shack, but he continued fighting. Later, Lund spotted Ainsley's rifle barrel protruding from behind the shack corner, fired, and forced Ainsley to retreat to cottonwood trees in the dry creek. Ainsley displayed fast hip shooting before moving behind a fallen tree, hoping to ambush advancing lawmen.
Lund got the drop on him and crept forward to force a surrender, but Ainsley spotted him and went for his gun. Lund fired, striking Ainsley in the chest; the bullet passed through Ainsley's body and killed a cow fifty yards up the ravine.
Aftermath
Ainsley's body was taken to the Blackwell Hotel, and Cravens was held in a third-story room there. During interrogation, Cravens refused to give information about his partner except to say his name was Dick, leading authorities to believe they had killed "Dynamite Dick" Clifton of the Wild Bunch, who also had three missing fingers. The real "Dynamite Dick" was killed in November 1897 by Chris Madsen. The U.S. Marshals office in Guthrie was informed, and Marshal Evett Dumas Nix led five deputies, including Frank M. Canton, to Blackwell.
When shown Ainsley's body, Nix said he did not know the man and that he was not Dan Clifton. In Cravens' room, Canton asked for the dead man's name; Cravens, coughing blood, asked for his father to be brought from Iowa.
Canton agreed, and Cravens' father arrived two days later, but Cravens survived his wounds and never gave an answer. Speculation continued that Ainsley was "Skeeter Dick" or "Three Fingered Dick," but eventually Cravens confirmed his partner was Dick Ainsley, or Buck McGregg. Ainsley's mother, escorted by two Lincoln County sheriffs, arrived in Blackwell and claimed her son's body for burial.
More in American Old West Gunfights
Sources
Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.
- Wikipedia: Blackwell gunfight (CC BY-SA 4.0).
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced