American Old West Gunfights Codexery

Shootout at Wilson Ranch

A feud over women led to a deadly shootout and a hanging.

Last updated

The Shootout at Wilson Ranch was a gunfight that led to the final and most famous hanging in Tombstone, Arizona. On April 7, 1899, two lawmen confronted the Halderman brothers at a ranch in the Chiricahua Mountains, resulting in the deaths of both officers. The brothers were captured, tried, and executed on November 16, 1900.

Background

William and Thomas Halderman, aged twenty-one and eighteen at their deaths, were members of the wealthy Kokernot family of Texas pioneers but worked as cowboys in Cochise County, Arizona. In 1898 they began feuding with eighteen-year-old Teddy Moore over two young women, Rena and Mary Wilson. Moore threatened to kill William in November 1898 and continued doing so for months. On April 6, 1899, Justice William Monmonier received a report from Buck Smith, owner of the Smith Ranch, accusing the Haldermans of stealing and killing cattle.

A warrant was issued, and Constable Chester Ainsworth—brother of Attorney General Charles F. Ainsworth—was tasked with the arrest. Ainsworth went to the Smith Ranch seeking help but was refused; he then went to the Moore Ranch and deputized Teddy Moore. The two-man posse found the Halderman house empty and proceeded to Wilson Ranch, owned by John W. Wilson, who lived there with his sons Johnny and Tol and daughters Rena and Mary.

Aftermath

Deputy Sid Mullen captured the brothers on April 12 while they were camped just across the New Mexico border east of Duncan. They were first held in Pearce jail, then transferred to Tombstone for trial. Early in June the court found them guilty of first-degree murder on June 11 and sentenced them to hang on August 10, 1900. The Haldermans' family tried to influence the court to prevent a stain on the name of a pioneer Texas family, achieving only a delay.

The brothers attempted to gather evidence that the cattle rustling allegations were false and that the shootout resulted from a feud; they claimed Moore had stolen the cattle and framed them to woo Rena Wilson. An appeal was sent, and with Governor Nathan O. Murphy out of state, the application went to President William McKinley, who granted a stay until October 5, 1900. Governor Murphy extended the stay, but the evidence did not materialize, and the execution date was set for November 16, 1900.

The family claimed the trial was unfair because the prosecutor was Attorney General Charles L. Ainsworth, the constable's brother, and the jury was eager for a hanging.

More in American Old West Gunfights

Sources

Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.

Spotted an error? Know more?

Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced

Comments

Loading…
Open in the interactive codex →