Anne Bonny

Lore & Background

Much of Bonny's background is unknown. The first biography of Bonny comes from Captain Charles Johnson's 1724 book A General History of the Pyrates. According to Johnson, Bonny was born in Ireland, the illegitimate daughter of an attorney and his servant. Bonny and her father later moved to Carolina, where she married a sailor. Although Johnson's version of events has become popular over the centuries, there is little evidence to support it. At an unknown date, Bonny travelled to the Bahamas where she became acquainted with the pirate John Rackham. In August 1720, Bonny joined Rackham's crew, alongside another female pirate, Mary Read. Together they stole the sloop William owned by John Ham from Nassau on 22 August 1720. Rackham and his crew carried out a number of attacks on merchant ships in the West Indies until they were captured by former privateer Jonathan Barnet following a brief naval engagement on 22 October 1720 near Jamaica. Rackham, along with all male crew members, were tried, sentenced, and executed, but Bonny and Read had their executions stayed due to both of them claiming to be pregnant. Read died in jail around mid April 1721, but Bonny was likely let go at an unknown point, living until 1733.

Reader's Guide

Bonny's date and place of birth are unknown. Nothing definitive is known about her early life. No primary source, including her own trial transcript, makes mention of her age or nation of origin. No Anne Bonny born in the late 17th or early 18th century has been found in the baptism records of Ireland, and it is possible she was not of Irish origin. Bonny is not noted to have been a colonist of Nassau prior to it becoming a pirates nest in 1713 under Benjamin Hornigold. Before 22 August 1720, little can be definitively said about Bonny's early life. All details concerning Bonny's early life stem from Captain Charles Johnson's A General History of the Pyrates (a greatly unreliable series of pirate biographies). Johnson claimed that Bonny was born in a town near Cork in the Kingdom of Ireland at an unspecified year. She was the daughter of a servant woman named Mary, and her employer, an unnamed attorney. Later versions of this story would refer to the attorney as William Cormac and the mother as Peg/Mary Brennan. These are fictional names first written down in John Carlova's 1964 romance novel Mistress of the Seas, which has been quoted as fact for many years by historians such as David Cordingly. The attorney's unnamed wife had become ill and was moved to her mother-in-law's home a few miles away to be cared for. While his wife was away for four months, the attorney began an affair with Mary. The attorney's wife discovered the affair following a comical mix up concerning silver spoons. This theatrical misunderstanding began with a tanner Mary knew stealing three silver spoons and hiding them in her bed. Mary called a constable on the man, but the spoons were not found. Upon the wife's return, the tanner told her the entire story about stealing silver spoons, but confessed it was only a joke. The wife found the three silver spoons in Mary's bed as the tanner had claimed. She became suspicious however, the tanner had noted he had hidden the silver spoons days ago. The wife questioned why Mary had not been sleeping in her bed. The wife then assumed her husband had been unfaithful the past four months. The wife stayed in the bed and waited for the attorney, who called for Mary and laid in her bed, confirming the affair. The wife then put the silver spoons back into the bed, and when Mary went to sleep, she found them and hid them in her trunk. The wife later acc

Did You Know?

• Bonny and Read joined Rackham's crew at the time of the theft of the sloop William on 22 August 1720, not before.
• Bonny's trial transcript does not mention her age or nation of origin.
• No James Bonny is recorded in Captain Vincent Pearse's list of pirates who took the King's Pardon.

The Enigma of Her Origins

Almost everything known about Anne Bonny's childhood rests on a single, deeply unreliable source: Captain Charles Johnson's 1724 compilation, A General History of the Pyrates. No baptismal record, trial transcript, or other primary document confirms her birth date, her place of origin, or even her age. Searches through Irish parish registers have turned up no Anne Bonny born in the late seventeenth or early eighteenth century, leaving open the possibility that she was never Irish at all. Johnson's narrative paints a melodramatic picture: an attorney's illicit affair with his servant Mary, a scandal exposed through a bizarre mix-up involving three stolen silver spoons, and a daughter born in prison. Later retellings, beginning with a 1964 romance novel, attached invented names to the unnamed characters, and those fabrications have been repeated as fact by respected historians. Johnson also claimed the attorney raised the infant as a boy before the ruse collapsed, that the family fled to Carolina, and that Bonny married a poor sailor against her father's wishes. Yet no documented case of a Carolinas attorney turning plantation owner with a daughter named Anne exists, and the entire account remains uncorroborated.

Two Women on Rackham's Deck

By the summer of 1720, Anne Bonny had made her way to the Bahamas, where she crossed paths with the pirate John Rackham. The precise circumstances of their meeting remain unrecorded, but by August she had joined his crew alongside another woman, Mary Read. Their first documented act together was the seizure of the sloop William, owned by a man named John Ham, taken from Nassau on 22 August 1720. From that point, Rackham and his crew carried out a series of raids on merchant vessels throughout the West Indies. Bonny and Read were not mere passengers; they were active members of the crew during these attacks. Their career at sea was brief but intense, lasting roughly two months before the crew's luck ran out. They were among the very few women whose presence aboard a pirate vessel during the Golden Age has left any trace in the historical record, making their short stretch of piracy an extraordinary footnote in an era dominated overwhelmingly by men.

The Gunfire, the Trial, and a Stayed Sentence

On 22 October 1720, near the coast of Jamaica, Rackham's vessel came under fire from Jonathan Barnet, a former privateer. The naval engagement was brief, and its outcome was decisive: Barnet's forces captured Rackham and his entire crew. In the aftermath, every male member of the crew was brought to trial, found guilty, sentenced to death, and executed. Bonny and Read, however, were granted a reprieve. Both women claimed they were pregnant, and the courts accepted their assertions, staying the sentences that would have ended their lives. The two fates diverged sharply after that point. Mary Read died in jail around mid-April 1721, her story ending in a cell. Bonny, by contrast, was released at some unknown date and lived on for roughly another twelve years, likely dying in December 1733. The pregnancy claims that saved her remain unverified, and the circumstances of her eventual release are lost to history. What is certain is that she outlived her crew, her companion, and the brief window of piracy that defined her name.

A Legend Built on a Single Unreliable Text

Anne Bonny has become one of the most widely recognized figures in the entire history of piracy, a status that is almost entirely the product of one book. Captain Charles Johnson's A General History of the Pyrates, published in 1724, is widely regarded as a highly unreliable collection of pirate biographies, yet it is the sole source for nearly every biographical detail associated with Bonny. The problem compounds over time: names that Johnson left blank were filled in by a 1964 novelist, and those invented names have since been quoted as historical fact by scholars including David Cordingly. The theatrical silver-spoon scandal, the attorney's plantation, the sailor husband James Bonny—none of it is corroborated by any independent record. No trial transcript mentions her age or nationality. No baptismal entry confirms an Irish birth. And yet, three centuries later, Bonny endures as an iconic symbol of the Golden Age, her legend inseparable from the very text that is its only foundation.

Common Misconceptions (Editorial)

One common misconception is that Anne Bonny was definitively Irish. While a popular early biography claims she was born in Ireland to an attorney and his servant, no primary source confirms her nationality, and no Anne Bonny from that period appears in Irish baptism records. Another misconception is that she was executed; in fact, she avoided execution by claiming pregnancy, and her ultimate fate remains unknown, though she likely lived until 1733.

Why It Matters (Editorial)

Anne Bonny endures as a symbol of defiance against gendered expectations, standing out in the male-dominated annals of piracy. Her story—shrouded in myth and sparse fact—reflects how historical figures can be shaped by unreliable sources and cultural fascination, reminding us to question even the most colorful tales from the past.

Gallery