Once Upon a Time in Wonderland

Lore & Background

The series follows Alice, who after the apparent death of her true love Cyrus, returns home to Victorian England and is placed in an asylum. Her doctors aim to cure her with a treatment that will make her forget everything about her tales in Wonderland. She is rescued by the Knave of Hearts and the White Rabbit and brought back to Wonderland to save Cyrus, who is discovered to be alive. In Wonderland, Alice must evade the plots of Jafar and the Red Queen while dealing with the whimsical dangers of Wonderland, including the Jabberwocky.

Reader's Guide

Once Upon a Time in Wonderland received mixed to positive reviews from critics, who praised its cast, visuals, and narrative, but criticized the plot. Rotten Tomatoes gave the series an approval rating of 59% based on 27 reviews, with an average rating of 6.03/10. The site's critical consensus reads: 'Once Upon a Time in Wonderland is attractive to the eye and pleasantly narrated, but it loses some luster due to a jumbled story and Wonderland's unlikable inhabitants.' The series has a score of 59/100 on Metacritic based on 23 critics, indicating 'mixed or average reviews.' The show was canceled on March 27, 2014, after one season. Michael Socha reprised his role as Will Scarlet / Knave of Hearts in Once Upon a Time as a series regular for its fourth season. The series became available to stream on Disney+ on November 27, 2020.

The Story of Alice's Return

After the apparent death of her beloved Cyrus, Alice finds herself back in Victorian England, confined to an asylum where her doctors intend to use a treatment that will erase all memory of her adventures in Wonderland. This desperate medical intervention is interrupted when the Knave of Hearts and the White Rabbit rescue her, dragging her back through the looking glass to a realm where Cyrus has been discovered alive. Now stranded once again in a world of perpetual chaos, Alice must navigate the schemes of two formidable antagonists—Jafar and the Red Queen—while confronting the bizarre and lethal creatures that call Wonderland home, including the terrifying Jabberwocky. The narrative threads together the whimsy of Lewis Carroll's 1865 and 1871 novels with the broader storytelling universe established by its parent series, Once Upon a Time, weaving in references to Disney properties and the television show Lost. The result is a story that balances romantic urgency with the unpredictable, often dangerous logic of a world where nothing operates by ordinary rules.

A Star-Studded Ensemble

The series assembled a notably eclectic cast that blended dramatic leads with high-profile voice talent. Sophie Lowe anchored the show as Alice, while Michael Socha brought a sardonic, action-driven energy to the triple role of Will Scarlet, the Knave of Hearts, and the White King. Peter Gadiot played Cyrus, Alice's love interest, and Emma Rigby took on the dual identity of Anastasia, shifting between the Red Queen and White Queen. Naveen Andrews, known for his work on Lost, joined as the villainous Jafar. The voice cast was particularly striking: John Lithgow lent his voice to Percy the White Rabbit, Keith David voiced the Cheshire Cat, Iggy Pop brought his rock-star persona to the Caterpillar, and Whoopi Goldberg provided the voice of Mrs. Rabbit. Peta Sergeant physically portrayed the monstrous Jabberwocky. Barbara Hershey made a guest appearance reprising her Once Upon a Time role as Cora, the Queen of Hearts, while Millie Bobby Brown appeared as a younger version of Alice.

Development and the Mad Hatter Controversy

Development on the spin-off began in February 2013, with Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz, Zack Estrin, and Jane Espenson at the helm for ABC Studios. One of the earliest creative decisions became a public controversy: initial reports indicated the Mad Hatter, played by Sebastian Stan in the parent series, would be recast because Stan was committed to portraying Bucky Barnes in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. However, after fan backlash and out of respect for Stan's performance, Kitsis confirmed the character would simply be absent from the new series rather than handed to another actor. ABC officially greenlit the project on May 10, 2013, and placed it in the Thursday night timeslot rather than using it as a fill-in for Once Upon a Time. Only 13 episodes were ordered, and Kitsis emphasized the show was designed to tell a complete story with a beginning, middle, and end rather than stretching material across multiple seasons. Casting announcements followed steadily through the spring and summer, with Sophie Lowe confirmed as Alice in late March and Naveen Andrews revealed as Jafar at Comic-Con.

Critical Response and Aftermath

Critics offered a divided but generally respectful assessment of the series. Rotten Tomatoes recorded a 59 percent approval rating across 27 reviews, with an average score of 6.03 out of 10, and its consensus praised the show's visual appeal and pleasant narration while faulting its tangled plot and the unlikable nature of Wonderland's inhabitants. Metacritic assigned a 59 out of 100 based on 23 critics, landing in the mixed-or-average range. Common Sense Media gave it four out of five stars, acknowledging the creative and often mature extrapolation of familiar fairy tales while cautioning that the show's violence—knives, swordplay, fistfights—made it unsuitable for young children. Despite these mixed signals, the series was canceled on March 27, 2014, after its single season, with the finale broadcast a week later on April 3. The show's most tangible legacy extended beyond its brief run: Michael Socha returned to the Once Upon a Time universe as a series regular in its fourth season, reprising his Wonderland character Will Scarlet, also known as the Knave of Hearts.

Gallery