Costume Quest 2

Lore & Background

Costume Quest 2 picks up where the DLC expansion of Costume Quest, 'Grubbins on Ice', left off. Everett, Lucy, Wren, and Reynold are trapped inside a nexus of portals and jump into one, arriving in a futuristic dental dystopia. There, they witness their dentist, Dr. Orel White, speaking with a time wizard and following him into a portal to the past. A man hiding in a bush, revealed to be an older Everett, opens another portal to the past (the 1960s), not to a future dystopia.

Reader's Guide

Costume Quest 2 is significant as a sequel that expands on the original's charm with new combat mechanics such as counters and double attacks. Its time travel plot allows players to explore a past before the children's hometown and a future dental dystopia, adding depth to the story. The game received mixed reviews, with critics noting that its new methods and abilities added charm, though navigation was considered iffy and the healing system somewhat broken. Despite its short runtime of roughly six hours, the humor and personality were praised, making it a notable entry in the Halloween-themed RPG genre. Its downloadable-only release across multiple platforms made it accessible to a wide audience.

Did You Know?

• Costume Quest 2 is the sequel to Costume Quest (2010).
• The game's plot involves time travel to both the past and a future dental dystopia.
• Players can choose to play as either twin sibling Wren or Reynold.

Combat & Exploration Mechanics

Costume Quest 2 reimagines the turn-based combat framework of its predecessor by letting players step into the shoes of either Wren or Reynold, the twin siblings at the heart of the story. Alongside their sibling and a rotating cast of allies discovered throughout the journey, the player navigates environments that span both the past—set before the children's hometown even existed—and a grim future defined by a dental dystopia. Core activities include exploring each zone, completing side quests, and engaging in the series' signature trick-or-treating. The real standout, however, is the overhauled battle system. When the party encounters monsters, they transform into gigantic costumed versions of themselves and fight in turn-based encounters. Double Fine introduced mechanics absent from the 2010 original, most notably counter-attacks and double-strike sequences, giving players more tactical depth and a sense of progression that the first title lacked. The combination of a time-splitting world and these expanded combat tools gives the sequel a noticeably richer feel.

A Story Spanning Three Timelines

The narrative of Costume Quest 2 picks up directly from the original game's "Grubbins on Ice" expansion, where Everett, Lucy, Wren, and Reynold are trapped inside a nexus of portals. After the player chooses which twin to control, the siblings are thrust back to Halloween night, only to witness their dentist, Dr. Orel White, speaking with a time wizard. That wizard opens a portal to the past, which Orel uses to escape. An older Everett, with his wife Lucy, then tasks the children with retrieving a talisman capable of opening a gateway to the monster world before Orel can claim it. In the past, a younger Orel obstructs their progress, and with the aid of a boy named Monty, the group locates the talisman—only for the future Orel to steal it. The children are captured in the dystopian future and imprisoned in a school, where they discover Everett and Lucy's daughter Halley. After escaping, they devise a plan involving a retinal scanner that only Orel can operate. Returning to the past, they recruit the younger Orel as an ally, who denounces his future self and helps defeat him in the climactic battle, leaving Dr. White redeemed in the present.

Development & Multi-Platform Release

Released in 2014, Costume Quest 2 was developed by Double Fine Productions and published by Midnight City, marking a notable shift in the studio's distribution approach. Rather than arriving on physical retail shelves, the title was made available exclusively as a digital download, a decision that reflected the industry's ongoing transition toward online storefronts. The game launched across a remarkably wide array of platforms, spanning Linux, OS X, Windows, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, Wii U, Xbox 360, and Xbox One—a breadth that underscored the publisher's commitment to reaching players wherever they gathered. As the direct sequel to the 2010 original Costume Quest, the follow-up carried the expectation of building on its predecessor's identity while introducing meaningful upgrades. The development team delivered on that promise with a time travel-based plotline that expanded the narrative scope considerably and an improved battle system that added layers of tactical choice. The combination of Double Fine's signature whimsical design sensibility with Midnight City's distribution infrastructure gave the project a distinctive identity within the role-playing genre, positioning it as a lighthearted yet mechanically evolved entry in the Halloween-themed gaming space.

Critical Response & Player Reception

Upon its 2014 release, Costume Quest 2 drew mixed reviews from the gaming press, though the general consensus acknowledged meaningful improvements over the 2010 original. Critics consistently praised the new combat abilities and methods, noting that they injected additional charm and tactical variety into encounters that the first game handled more simply. IGN's review captured this sentiment well, calling both the combat and the story "surprisingly good" for a role-playing game that wraps up in roughly a half-dozen hours. However, the review also flagged specific mechanical concerns: navigation through the environments was described as "iffy," and the healing system remained somewhat broken even after a major revision was patched in. Despite these rough edges, the game's humor and personality were widely cited as its greatest strengths, with reviewers emphasizing that the writing and tone carried the experience. IGN ultimately characterized the title as a "good Halloween bounty," a phrase that neatly encapsulated the game's identity as a fun, seasonal treat rather than a sprawling epic. The overall reception suggested that while Costume Quest 2 was not without flaws, its charm and improved systems made it a satisfying evolution of the franchise.

Gallery