Agony (2018 video game)

Lore & Background

Agony was inspired by Dante's Inferno and research into the topic, with a first concept video created by Tomasz Dutkiewicz in 2015. The popularity of that video led to further development, and Madmind Studio was formed with help from fans and investors, beginning development in January 2016. A Kickstarter campaign launched in November 2016 surpassed its goal and ended in December 2016. The game was originally scheduled for 30 March 2018 but was delayed to 29 May 2018.

The story follows a lost soul trapped in hell without memory of his former life, later revealed to be a king who made a Faustian bargain with the Red Goddess. The protagonist is referred to as both Nimrod and Amraphel. The player can possess other martyrs and demons, solve puzzles, and collect hidden statues and paintings. Multiple endings exist, but only two are canonical. To avoid an Adults Only rating from the ESRB, content was censored; a planned restoration patch was dropped due to legal issues, but an unrated version titled Agony Unrated was released on Steam on 31 October 2018.

Reception was generally unfavorable, with critics noting ambitious horror art but repetitive gameplay, slow movement, sparse save points, and unclear possession mechanics. The game's depiction of hell was praised as a 'breathtaking achievement' and a 'pulsating gothic nightmare,' but enemy design and overuse of gore drew criticism. A spin-off game titled Succubus was announced in December 2018.

Reader's Guide

Agony is notable as the debut title of Madmind Studio, a Polish developer formed after a successful Kickstarter campaign. Its depiction of hell, inspired by Dante's Inferno, was widely praised for its grotesque and detailed environments, but the game's gameplay—particularly its stealth mechanics, slow movement, and sparse checkpoints—was heavily criticized. The controversy over censorship for console release and the subsequent release of Agony Unrated on PC highlighted tensions between artistic vision and platform restrictions. The game's generally unfavorable reviews reflect a divide between its ambitious visual design and repetitive, frustrating gameplay. Its legacy includes a spin-off, Succubus, and ports to Nintendo Switch and VR, indicating continued interest in its setting despite mixed reception.

Did You Know?

• The game was delayed from 30 March 2018 to 29 May 2018.
• Agony Unrated was released on Steam on 31 October 2018 with restored content and quality-of-life improvements.

The Descent: Gameplay & Survival Mechanics

Agony places the player in a first-person perspective as a nameless, memoryless soul condemned to the pits of hell. The protagonist, known variously as Amraphel or Nimrod, must navigate a nightmarish landscape with the singular goal of reaching the Red Goddess to secure a path back to the living world. What distinguishes the experience from typical survival horror is the possession mechanic: the player can seize control of other martyrs and, as the story progresses, both lesser and higher-ranking demons, unlocking new abilities that become essential for survival. Stealth plays a central role, with crouching and breath-holding mechanics allowing the player to slip past patrolling demons. Puzzle-solving gates access to new regions of hell, while hidden statues and scattered paintings reward explorers who take the time to look around. The combination of stealth, possession, and environmental puzzles creates a loop that, while ambitious in scope, was frequently criticized for growing repetitive over the course of a full playthrough.

A Faustian Bargain: Narrative & Endings

The story follows a tormented soul who awakens in hell with no recollection of his former existence. Fragments of his past gradually surface: he was once a king of an ancient land who struck a Faustian bargain with the Red Goddess, one of the creators of hell. The goddess calls him Nimrod, while the other condemned souls he encounters know him as Amraphel and blame him for their damnation, citing atrocities he committed during his mortal life. Driven by the promise of escape, the protagonist journeys to the Red Goddess's lair. In the canonical path where the player obeys her commands, the journey leads to hell's lowest depths, where the player must provoke and wear down a colossal entity known only as the Beast. By possessing the Beast and shattering the seals that bind it, the protagonist triggers the Goddess's true plan: she reveals herself as the Whore of Babylon and vows to unleash the Apocalypse. The protagonist is briefly returned to the living world, only to be slain by the Beast moments later, his soul dragged back to hell as the Goddess begins her conquest of Earth. Multiple endings exist based on player choices, though only two are considered canonical.

From Concept to Controversy: Development & the Rating Battle

The seeds of Agony were planted in 2015 when Tomasz Dutkiewicz produced a concept video inspired by Dante's Divine Comedy. Its popularity led him and colleagues to form Madmind Studio, with development beginning in January 2016. A Kickstarter campaign launched in November 2016 exceeded its funding goal by December. The team chose Unreal Engine 4 and a first-person perspective, citing Outlast and Amnesia as models for immersive horror. Dutkiewicz expressed frustration that the genre had grown stagnant with repetitive action-focused clones, and wanted to return horror to its roots by setting the game in hell. The road to release, however, was marred by a content-rating crisis. To secure a Mature ESRB rating rather than an Adults Only designation—which would have blocked PlayStation 4 and Xbox One releases—the developers altered certain content. They initially promised a PC patch to restore censored material, but that patch was abandoned due to legal issues. Instead, Agony Unrated launched as a separate Steam title on October 31, 2018, featuring updated graphics, new enemies, additional endings, and gameplay improvements. Kickstarter backers received it free, while existing owners could purchase it at a 90% discount.

Reception & the Long Tail of Ports

Agony's launch in May 2018 was met with generally unfavorable reviews, with Metacritic aggregating the critical consensus as negative. IGN's David Jagneaux captured a common sentiment, describing the game as a blend of ambitious, bold horror artistry and repetitive gameplay mechanics. The detailed environments depicting hell were praised for their nightmarish quality, but the execution fell short of the vision. The developers themselves acknowledged the disappointment, noting that numerous technical errors and the censored content effectively distracted players from the experience they had intended. In the years following release, Madmind Studio worked to extend the game's life across platforms. A partnership with Forever Entertainment brought Agony to the Nintendo Switch, released on October 31, 2019. In November 2020, Ignibit announced a collaboration to bring the game to virtual reality, a version that finally launched on April 5, 2023. These extended releases, combined with the Agony Unrated update, represent the studio's ongoing effort to refine and share a project that, despite its critical reception, maintained a dedicated following through its bold thematic ambitions.

Gallery