Cultural Depictions of Alexander the Great Codexery

Aristotle and the Gun

A time traveler tries to change Aristotle's methods.

Last updated

L. Sprague de Camp's 1958 tale "Aristotle and the Gun" follows a scientist who travels to ancient Macedonia to steer Aristotle toward experimental science, only to create a backward alternate present. The story is known for its detailed ancient setting and its twist on the consequences of meddling with history.

Publication history

The story first appeared in the magazine Astounding Science-Fiction for February, 1958. It was first collected in de Camp's A Gun for Dinosaur and Other Imaginative Tales (Doubleday, 1963), and later appeared in the paperback edition from Curtis Books in 1969.

Subsequent collections include Aristotle and the Gun and Other Stories (Five Star, 2002) and Years in the Making: the Time-Travel Stories of L. Sprague de Camp (NESFA Press, 2005). It has been anthologized in Alpha Three, Space Mail, Volume II, Analog: Writers' Choice, Robert Adams' Book of Alternate Worlds, The Legend Book of Science Fiction, Modern Classics of Science Fiction, Roads Not Taken: Tales of Alternate History, and Futures Past. A stand-alone paperback edition was published by Positronic Publishing in April, 2013. The story has also been translated into German.

Plot summary

Sherman Weaver, a lonely and misanthropic scientist, is central to a secret US government project to build a time machine. After the prototype is constructed, the government, alarmed by Weaver's report that small historical changes could have profound consequences, orders the project aborted. Instead of dismantling the machine, Weaver projects himself back to the era of Philip II of Macedon to meet Aristotle. He believes Aristotle's lack of interest in experiment retarded scientific progress, and aims to nudge him toward experimentation to create a super-scientific 20th century.

Pretending to be a traveler from India, Weaver uses modern marvels to demonstrate the value of experimentation. His task is complicated by the malicious mischief of Aristotle's students, including the young Prince Alexander, and by suspicion of being a spy for the Great King of Persia.

Forced to defend himself with a handgun, Weaver is nearly executed for espionage and murder but is snapped back to the present as the time projection wears off. He finds a world far different from his own: Aristotle, convinced that experimental knowledge is beneath philosophers, wrote against it, leading to a backward present of petty states at a late medieval level. Weaver is enslaved for many years until his scholarly talents are recognized.

Reception

Critic P. Schuyler Miller called the story "even better" than de Camp's "A Gun for Dinosaur" in its recreation of Aristotle's Macedonia and its twist on the alternate time-track theme. Don D'Ammassa rated it one of de Camp's "best stories" and of "particular note" among his many memorable short stories. Roland Green, writing for Booklist, called it of "outstanding merit" and a "vintage short piece." Tom Easton described it as "a classic exposition of the time-travel paradox." Harry Turtledove called it "a fine specimen of the for-want-of-a-nail story" where things are not as easy as the protagonist thought.

Importance

"Aristotle and the Gun" is one of de Camp's most notable works. Like his earlier alternate history novel Lest Darkness Fall (1939), it posits a world changed by time travel, and like "The Wheels of If" (1940), it reveals long-term consequences of historical change.

For de Camp, its publication marked the beginning of a lengthy departure from science fiction, pointing toward the historical novels of the ancient world he would write over the next ten years, starting with An Elephant for Aristotle (1958). The story's meticulously researched depiction of the Classical Greek and Hellenistic milieu foreshadows this shift. De Camp would write no more science fiction until 1977.

More in Cultural Depictions of Alexander the Great

Sources

Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.

Spotted an error? Know more?

Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced

Comments

Loading…
Open in the interactive codex →