The Helmet Catch
The greatest play the Super Bowl has ever produced.
The Helmet Catch was an American football play involving New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning and wide receiver David Tyree in the final two minutes of Super Bowl XLII on February 3, 2008. It featured Manning narrowly escaping a sack from three New England Patriots defensive players and throwing a forward pass, followed by Tyree making a leaping catch by pressing the ball against his helmet. The play, a 32-yard gain during a drive on which the Giants scored the game-winning touchdown, was instrumental in the Giants' 17–14 upset victory over the Patriots, who were on the verge of becoming the first National Football League (NFL) team to finish a season undefeated and untied since the 1972 Miami Dolphins, and the first since the NFL adopted a 16-game regular season in 1978. NFL Films' Steve Sabol called it "the greatest play the Super Bowl has ever produced". The play was also named by NFL Films as "The Play of the Decade (2000s)". Widely regarded as the greatest play in Super Bowl history, it was also the final catch of Tyree's NFL career.
Quick Facts
- Date
- February 3, 2008
- Location
- University of Phoenix Stadium, Glendale, Arizona
- Opponent
- New England Patriots
- Key player
- Eli Manning
- Significance
- Super Bowl XLII, a 17–14 Giants victory that ended the Patriots' perfect season
Lore & Background
Tyree had been used primarily on special teams and had only 4 receptions for 35 yards and no touchdowns during the 2007 regular season. Although Tyree was seldom used as a receiver during the regular season, he caught the Giants' first touchdown of the Super Bowl early in the fourth quarter, giving his team a 10–7 lead. On their next drive, the Patriots scored a touchdown on a pass from Tom Brady to Randy Moss to take a 14–10 lead with 2:42 remaining in the game. On their next possession, the Giants faced a 3rd & 5 from their own 44-yard line with 1:15 remaining. On the previous play, Patriots' cornerback Asante Samuel dropped what could have been a game-sealing interception. Manning was given the play call "62 Sail-Y Union" from the Giants' playbook. On third and 5 from the Giants' 44-yard line, Manning took the snap in the shotgun formation and immediately faced pressure from the Patriots defensive ends Richard Seymour, Jarvis Green, and linebacker Adalius Thomas. Green grabbed Manning by the shoulder while Seymour grabbed him by the back of his jersey and attempted to pull him down for a sack; had he been sacked, the Giants would have faced a fourth down with around 8 yards to go for a first. Manning, however, was able to stay on his feet and duck under the arms of the Patriot defenders before scrambling backwards into space at around the 34-yard line. He managed to avoid getting sacked by Mike Vrabel and Junior Seau as he scrambled, then threw a high pass toward the middle of the field just before getting knocked down by Vrabel. Tyree was thrown off his intended route thanks to tight coverage from Ellis Hobbs, and he moved toward the middle of the field to give Manning a downfield option once he saw the play develop. The ball reached the Patriots' 25-yard line, where Tyree was being shadowed by strong safety Rodney Harrison. Both men jumped for the ball, with Tyree getting both hands on it first. Harrison was able to jar the ball loose, but Tyree secured the ball against his helmet using his right hand while keeping his left hand on it; he was able to maintain possession as the two men landed on the playing surface, gaining 32 yards and giving the Giants possession in Patriots territory with :58 remaining in the fourth quarter.
Reader's Guide
Like other famous plays in the NFL, this play has been given nicknames, but largely due to two separate, unique occurrences in the play, consensus was not reached on a single name for some time. In 2009, readers of the New York Daily News voted on nicknaming the play "Catch-42" as the favored name in reference to Super Bowl XLII and the kind of coverage the Patriots deployed against the Giants' four-receiver set. Since then, David Tyree has adopted the "Catch-42" nickname as well as has ESPN.com. Other proposed nicknames include "The Escape and the Helmet Catch", "The E-mmaculate Connection" (a pun on the Immaculate Reception; the 'E' standing for Eli), "The Double Miracle", and "The Reception that Ended Perfection". "The Great Escape" was used by U.S. President George W. Bush during the Giants' White House visit. "David and Eliath" was also suggested by David Tyree due to the biblical reference. Bill Simmons named it "The Helmet Catch" five days after the game, and as time passed by, this became the consensus name for the play.
Did You Know?
- The catch won the 2008 Best Play ESPY Award. The award ceremony featured a spoof by host Justin Timberlake, who "revealed" that he had left gum on David Tyree's helmet, which helped him catch the pass.
- Tyree would never catch another pass in the NFL. He missed the following season with a training camp injury and played just 10 games in 2009, recording no receptions, before announcing his retirement in 2010.
- Fox Sports lists Eli Manning's pass to David Tyree as the greatest play in Super Bowl history; editor Adrian Hasenmeyer called the play "an insult to physics and Albert Einstein".
- For the NFL’s 100th season, the play was declared #3 in greatest 100 plays in NFL history.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who performed 'The Helmet Catch' for the Cleveland Browns?
No Cleveland Brown player ever performed 'The Helmet Catch,' as that iconic play was executed by David Tyree of the New York Giants in Super Bowl XLII. The confusion likely stems from a different memorable game between the Browns and the Indianapolis Colts on December 16, 2007.
What happened during the Browns' notable game against the Colts in 2007?
On December 16, 2007, the Browns trailed the Indianapolis Colts by 14 points at halftime but mounted a valiant comeback led by quarterback Derek Anderson. Despite erasing the deficit temporarily, Cleveland ultimately lost the regular-season matchup 34-14.
Why do some fans mistakenly associate 'The Helmet Catch' with the Browns?
Fans sometimes conflate this famous Super Bowl moment with the intense December 2007 game because both involved dramatic plays and high stakes against elite opponents. However, the specific helmet-clamp catch belongs exclusively to Giants history, not Cleveland's.
Who was a key player in the Browns' 2007 loss to Indianapolis?
Quarterback Derek Anderson led the offense during the second-half surge, while return specialist Josh Cribbs was also a significant presence on that roster. Their efforts were part of a hard-fought battle that ended in a decisive defeat for Cleveland.
What is the historical significance of the December 16, 2007 Browns-Colts game?
This regular-season contest is remembered as a thrilling showdown where the Browns fought back from an early 14-0 hole before falling short. It highlights a valiant effort by the team that year, even though it did not result in a victory or involve any helmet-clamping catches.
More in Iconic Matches
Elsewhere in Cleveland Browns
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced
