Castles in Syria Codexery

Castle of al-Al

A short-lived Crusader castle on the Golan Heights, known only from a single chronicler and now considered legendary.

Last updated

The Castle of al-Al, also called ʿAlʿāl or Qal'at al-'Al, appears only in the writings of the Damascene chronicler Ibn al-Qalanisi, a contemporary politician and historian. He records that the Franks built it in 1105 near the village of al-‘Al on the Golan Heights, under the direction of Hugh of Saint Omer, whom King Baldwin I had placed in charge of Galilee.

Al-Qalanisi places the site "between the Sawad and al-Bathaniya." The castle was short-lived: Toghtekin, the atabeg of Damascus, captured it on December 24 of that same year, returning to Damascus with a large amount of booty. According to al-Qalanisi, Toghtekin acted out of fear that once the supposedly impregnable castle was finished, it would be much harder to dismantle. The chronicler does not explicitly say Toghtekin demolished it.

Later Muslim historians, such as Sibt ibn al-Jawzi and Ibn al-Athir, added details they likely drew from al-Qalanisi’s account. Al-Jawzi writes that Toghtekin’s attack happened at night and that his return to Damascus occurred later, in February or March 1106. Both al-Jawzi and Ibn al-Athir state the garrison numbered at least 200 men, and that Toghtekin destroyed the castle after judging it too exposed to Frankish counterattacks.

Israeli historian Moshe Sharon, in his Corpus Inscriptionum Arabicarum Palaestinae, argues that no such castle ever existed. He suggests the story began when someone linked the Arabic name of a site, Qasr Bardawil (where qasr means castle), with the Crusader king Baldwin I, whom Arabic chronicles call Bardawil.

Sharon believes the entire legend—including the construction date of 1105 and the involvement of Hugh of Saint Omer, who did build Toron—was copied from one author to the next, from medieval chroniclers to modern historians like Runciman and Prawer. An archaeological survey conducted by Israeli archaeologists in 1968, published in 1972, dated the site of Qasr Bardawil to the Middle Bronze Age, not the Crusader period. This identification has since been abandoned.

The castle was one of three Crusader fortifications in the region, along with Chastel Neuf and Toron. According to the chronicles, the unfinished castle of al-Al was first used in 1105.

Hugh was killed while returning there after a successful raid into Damascene territory. Toghtekin, unwilling to allow a Frankish stronghold less than two days’ march from Damascus, attacked and easily captured the site, killing or taking the defenders. The Franks then abandoned it as too difficult to defend and relocated to Cave de Suète.

Crusader findings at al-'Al

A 1969 survey of the village of al-‘Al uncovered pottery typical of the Crusader period in the village center, over an area of about 100 dunams (roughly 25 acres). Possible Crusader-period findings also include large ashlars with chiselled margins in traces of walls beneath the modern village, which might indicate a large medieval building once protected the spring in the wadi below—possibly associated with the fortress.

Location and description

Qasr Bardawil, an archaeological site on the Golan Heights, holds the ruins of a fortified settlement. It sits on a triangular rocky spur about 110 meters from north to south, with a northern side roughly 90 meters wide. The spur is bordered by slopes to the east and west; the level northern approach was once protected by a faint ditch and a casemate wall, of which only traces of oval and rectangular chambers remain, along with collapsed unmortared masonry.

Its strategic position could have controlled the Roman road from Baysan to Damascus, and it lies about 12 kilometers east of the Lake of Tiberias. Paul Deschamps surveyed the area in the 1930s and identified Qasr Bardawil with the Crusader castle mentioned by al-Qalanisi, arguing it dominated a village called al-‘Al.

Rejection

The name Bardawil is the Arabic rendering of the Frankish name Baldwin, and the site’s location seemed to fit. However, the 1968 survey concluded that its main habitation period was the Middle Bronze Age II, and Denys Pringle lists Qasr Bardawil under “Rejects” in his gazetteer of Crusader fortifications due to a lack of medieval material. The survey results thus exclude it from being the Crusader castle mentioned by al-Qalanisi.

Quick Facts

Built
1105 (per Ibn al-Qalanisi)
Builder
Hugh of Saint Omer
Location
Near al-‘Al, Golan Heights
Primary source
Ibn al-Qalanisi (Damascene chronicler)
Captured by
Toghtekin, atabeg of Damascus
Date of capture
December 24, 1105 (per Qalanisi)

Facts from the source article.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who built the Castle of al-Al?

According to the sole surviving account, Hugh of Saint Omer—Baldwin I's appointed governor of Galilee—constructed the site in 1105. No other contemporary source confirms his involvement.

Where exactly was the Castle of al-Al situated?

Ibn al-Qalanisi places it 'between the Sawad and al-Bathaniya,' near the settlement of al-'Al on the Golan Heights. No modern archaeological dig has yet pinpointed its precise footprint.

How did the Castle of al-Al fall?

Toghtekin, the atabeg of Damascus, captured it on December 24, 1105, just weeks after its reported construction. This made it one of the shortest-lived Crusader strongholds in the region.

More in Castles in Syria

Sources

Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.

Spotted an error? Know more?

Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced

Comments

Loading…
Open in the interactive codex →