Pittsburgh Pirates Codexery

Cincinnati Reds

The Cincinnati Reds: A storied franchise with five World Series titles and a legacy of firsts.

The Cincinnati Reds are an American professional baseball team based in Cincinnati. The Reds compete in Major League Baseball (MLB) as a member club of the National League (NL) Central Division. They were a charter member of the American Association in 1882 before joining the NL in 1890.

character
Historic Rivalry
Affiliation
National League (NL)
Status
Active
Notable_Eras
1900s-1920s, 1970s, 2010s

Verified Timeline

188118821887189019011903190919191925194019601969197019711972197519761979199019931994199520132025

Lore & Background

The Reds played in the NL West division from 1969 to 1993, before joining the Central division in 1994. Cincinnati is generally considered to be the most dominant team of the 1970s. During this decade, they won the National League pennant five times, ultimately winning the World Series twice, in 1975 and 1976. The team was colloquially known as the 'Big Red Machine' during this time, and it included Hall of Fame members Johnny Bench, Joe Morgan, and Tony Pérez, as well as the controversial Pete Rose, the all-time hits leader in Major League Baseball. Despite their decorated past, the Reds have struggled in recent years, and currently have the longest drought of not winning a playoff series of any MLB team, with their last win coming in 1995. Overall, the Reds have won five World Series championships, nine NL pennants, one AA pennant and 10 division titles. The team plays its home games at Great American Ball Park, which opened in 2003. Bob Castellini has been the CEO of the Reds since 2006. From 1882 to 2025, the Reds' overall win–loss record is 11,017–10,845–139 (a .504 winning percentage).

In Their Own Story

In June 1970, both teams moved into new ballparks—the Reds to Riverfront Stadium and the Pirates to Three Rivers Stadium. On July 16, 1970, the Pirates opened Three Rivers Stadium against the Reds. Cincinnati's Tony Perez hit the park's first home run, and Willie Stargell homered for the Pirates. The game was decided on a 9th inning RBI single from Lee May, giving the Reds a 3-2 win. The 1972 NLCS saw a dramatic Game 5: after a 90-minute rain delay, the Pirates led 3–2 in the fifth inning, but the Reds scored 2 runs after a wild pitch by Pirates reliever Bob Moose with George Foster on third, and Hal McCrae hit a 2-run homer in the next at-bat to end the series. This was the final game ever played for Pirates Hall-of-Famer Roberto Clemente, who died in a plane crash in December.

Reader's Guide

The origins of the modern Cincinnati Reds baseball team can be traced back to the expulsion from the National League of an earlier team bearing the same name. In 1876, Cincinnati became one of the charter members of the new National League (NL), but the club ran afoul of league organizer and longtime president William Hulbert for selling beer during games and renting out its ballpark on Sundays. Both were important in enticing the city's large German population to support the team. While Hulbert made clear his distaste for both beer and Sunday baseball at the founding of the league, neither practice was against league rules at the time. On October 6, 1880, however, seven of the eight team owners adopted a pledge to ban both beer and Sunday baseball at the regular league meeting in December. Only Cincinnati president W. H. Kennett refused to sign the pledge, so the other owners preemptively expelled Cincinnati from the league for violating the new rules even though they were not yet in effect. Cincinnati's expulsion incensed Cincinnati Enquirer sports editor O. P. Caylor, who made two attempts to form a new league on behalf of the receivers for the now-bankrupt Reds franchise. When these attempts failed, he formed a new independent ball club in the spring of 1881 and brought the team to St. Louis for a weekend exhibition. The Reds' first game was a 12–3 victory over the St. Louis club. After the 1881 series proved successful, Caylor and former Reds president Justus Thorner received an invitation from Philadelphia businessman Horace Phillips to attend a meeting of several clubs in Pittsburgh, planning to establish a new league to compete with the NL. Upon arriving, however, Caylor and Thorner found that no other owners had accepted the invitation, while even Phillips declined to attend his own meeting. By chance, the duo met former pitcher Al Pratt, who paired them with former Pittsburgh Alleghenys president H. Denny McKnight. Together, the three hatched a scheme to form a new league by sending a telegram to each of the owners who were invited to attend the meeting stating that he was the only person who did not attend, and that everyone else was enthusiastic about the new venture and eager to attend a second meeting in Cincinnati. The ploy worked, and the American Association (AA) was officially formed at the Hotel Gibson in Cincinnati. The new Reds – with Th

Did You Know?

Historical Origins and Divisional Alignment

The Pirates and Reds were both founded in 1881 in the American Association, beginning play in 1882 and playing each other for five seasons. The Pirates moved into the National League in 1887, ceasing play between the two teams. The Reds moved into the National League in 1890, resuming play against the Pirates which continues to today. From 1969 to 1993, the Pirates were a member of the NL East until the league's realignment in 1993 moved them to the newly formed Central Division. Meanwhile, the Reds were previously members of the NL West until the realignment placed them in the same division as Pittsburgh in 1993.

Championship Parity and Postseason Encounters

The Pirates have won 5 World Series Championships in 1909, 1925, 1960, 1971, and 1979, and 9 NL Pennants. The Reds have also won 5 World Series Championships in 1919, 1940, 1975, 1976, and 1990, and 9 NL Pennants. Both teams have met 6 times in the postseason, including 5 meetings in the NLCS. As of the end of the 2025 season, the Pirates lead the regular season rivalry 1,254–1,234–18; however, the Reds lead in postseason wins 13–8. Most recently, both teams met in the 2013 National League Wild Card Game.

The Fierce 1970s NLCS Battles

In June 1970, both the Reds and Pirates moved into new ballparks—the Reds left Crosley Field for Riverfront Stadium, while the Pirates left Forbes Field for Three Rivers Stadium. On July 16, 1970, the Pirates opened Three Rivers Stadium against the Reds. Cincinnati's Tony Perez hit the park's first home run, and Willie Stargell homered for the Pirates. The Reds won 3-2 on a 9th inning RBI single from Lee May. The two teams met in the 1970 NLCS, and the Reds won in a sweep. In the 1972 NLCS, the Pirates won Game 1 5-1, but the Reds won Game 2. Game 3 saw a 3-2 Pirates victory. Game 4 was a blowout Reds win. Game 5 began with a 90-minute rain delay; the Pirates led 3-2 after the fifth inning, but the Reds scored 2 runs after a wild pitch by Bob Moose with George Foster on third, and Hal McCrae hit a 2-run homer in the next at-bat to end the series. This was the final game for Pirates Hall-of-Famer Roberto Clemente. In the 1975 NLCS, the Reds swept the Pirates in 3 games, though the Pirates forced Game 3 into 10 innings. In the 1979 NLCS, the Pirates swept the Reds.

Early Struggles and Scandal-Tainted Glory

During the infancy of the National League, both teams struggled. The Pirates saw most of their roster decimated as most had defected to the Players' League. Pittsburgh managed three straight NL Pennants from 1901 to 1903 and a World Series victory in 1909. Cincinnati fared much worse, failing to qualify for the postseason every season until 1919. The team arguably only won the 1919 World Series against the heavily-favored Chicago White Sox because of the Black Sox Scandal. While the Reds weren't involved in the scandal, it tainted the legitimacy of their first World Series championship. The Pirates won another World Series in 1925. The Reds won the World Series in 1940 while the Pirates were in a playoff drought. The Pirates won the World Series in 1960; the Reds won the pennant the following season but lost the World Series to the Yankees in five games. Both teams spent the 1960s in a rebuild.

Gallery

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the official name of this rivalry?

Fans and historians refer to this matchup as the River City Rivalry due to the Ohio River separating the two cities. It remains one of the most storied competitions in Major League Baseball history.

How far back does the competition go?

The rivalry originated in the late 19th century when both clubs emerged as industrial powerhouses. Their history includes legendary eras like the dead-ball period and modern National League Central battles.

Why is the geography significant to fans?

The geographic proximity creates a natural tension between Pittsburgh and Cincinnati supporters living on opposite banks. This closeness intensifies every game played between these two historic franchises.

Which specific decades were most notable?

Key moments occurred during the early 1900s, the dominant 1970s, and intense playoff races in the 2010s. These periods showcase the shifting balance of power between the two teams over time.

Is the rivalry still active today?

Both organizations are currently active within the National League and face off regularly each season. Their ongoing status ensures this historic feud continues for future generations of fans.

More in Great Rivalries

Related in Pittsburgh Pirates

Links follow this subject's own source article.

Elsewhere in the Pittsburgh Pirates universe

Spotted an error? Know more?

This is a living reference — every entry is fact-audited, and reader corrections feed straight into our audit queue. Suggest an edit · See this site's audit record

Comments

Loading…
Open in the interactive codex →