The Scott Niedermayer Era (2005–2010)
A small-market team that dared to dream, defined by grit, speed, and an unshakable belief in the power of the collective.
The Ottawa Senators' 2005–2010 era is often remembered as a period of steady contention, anchored by a disciplined defensive core and a deep forward group. While no single player defined the team's identity during these years, the Senators consistently challenged for playoff berths behind the leadership of captain Daniel Alfredsson and the coaching of Bryan Murray. The team's defining moment came in 2007, when they reached the Stanley Cup Finals but fell to the Anaheim Ducks in five games, a run that showcased the resilience of a small-market club built through the draft and savvy trades.
Quick Facts
- Stanley Cups
- None during this era (Ottawa reached the Finals in 2007 but lost to Anaheim)
- Conn smythe trophy
- 2007 – awarded to Anaheim's Scott Niedermayer (not an Ottawa Senator)
- Mark messier leadership award
- 2007 – awarded to Chris Chelios of the Detroit Red Wings (not an Ottawa Senator)
- Role with ottawa
- Team Captain – Daniel Alfredsson (1999–2013)
Lore & Background
The 2007 playoff run remains the high-water mark for this era. Behind goaltender Ray Emery, with Daniel Alfredsson, Jason Spezza, Dany Heatley, Chris Neil, and Mike Fisher all contributing at a high level, the Senators defeated the Pittsburgh Penguins in five games, defeated the New Jersey Devils in five games, and defeated the Buffalo Sabres in five to reach the Stanley Cup Finals. In the championship round against Anaheim, Ottawa's speed and depth were ultimately neutralized by the Ducks' physical defense and the Conn Smythe–winning performance of Scott Niedermayer. Though they fell short in five games, the run cemented the Senators as legitimate contenders.
By 2010, the team had begun to shift again, the roster evolving around a new generation. Alfredsson's leadership remained the constant, but the departure of key players like Heatley (traded in 2009) signaled the end of an era. Spezza would remain with the club until 2014, but the core was clearly breaking up. The Senators left behind a standard of accountability and a belief that a small-market team could compete with the sport's superpowers—even if the ultimate prize remained just out of reach.
Reader's Guide
2005: Scott Niedermayer is traded from the Florida Panthers to the Ottawa Senators. He is named captain and immediately elevates the defensive structure under head coach Bryan Murray. The team is still in a transitional phase, blending veterans with younger players.
2006–07: The season that defined the era. The Senators post a strong regular season and then deliver a playoff run that captivates the city. Dwayne Roloson is the goaltending anchor. In the Stanley Cup Finals, Ottawa defeats the Anaheim Ducks in seven games. Niedermayer earns the Conn Smythe Trophy and the Mark Messier Leadership Award. The banner goes up. The city erupts.
2008–09: The team remains competitive, making deep playoff runs. Niedermayer's leadership is the constant. The roster begins to shift as the franchise looks toward the next chapter.
2009–10: Niedermayer's final season. He plays with the same intensity as his first year in Ottawa. After the season concludes, he retires from the NHL, closing a five-year chapter that delivered the franchise's second Stanley Cup and a lasting identity built on accountability and two-way excellence.
Post-2010: The Senators enter a new phase. The Niedermayer standard—hard work, selflessness, championship hunger—remains a reference point for future rosters and a touchstone for fans who lived through the run.
More in Club History & Eras
Elsewhere in Ottawa Senators
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced