Partition (politics)
Last updated
In politics, a partition is when a territory that was once united gets split into two or more separate areas. This is different from secession, which happens inside already recognized countries. Brendan O’Leary points out that partition redraws borders through a place that at least one community sees as its homeland. Arie Dubnov and Laura Robson describe it as carving up land along ethnic or religious lines to create distinct nation-states.
History
Historically, Dubnov and Robson trace partition to the period after World War I, when new ideas about ethnicity, nationhood, and citizenship took shape. Post-war agreements, like the League of Nations mandates, promoted ethnic separatism as part of national self-determination, while also masking the continued expansion of French and British imperial power.
After World War II, they argue, partition shifted from a colonial tactic to a standard tool of global diplomacy. Ranabir Samaddar agrees that partition became more common after World War I, especially with the breakup of the Ottoman and Austro-Hungarian empires, driven by competing nationalist goals. By then, ethnicity was the main reason given for drawing borders.
Scholars often link partition to violence. Dubnov and Robson point to the Partition of Ireland as a precedent, noting that earlier population transfers in former Ottoman territories helped create national “majorities” and “minorities.” They emphasize that partitions after Ireland often included plans to move “inconvenient populations” alongside forced territorial splits, which led to violent outcomes for local people tasked with making new states ethnically homogeneous.
T.G. Fraser observes that Britain proposed partition in both Ireland and Palestine to solve conflicts between rival national groups, but it didn’t stop communal violence—it just gave those conflicts a “new dimension.” A. Dirk Moses argues that partition doesn’t really solve minority problems; it just moves them into new borders, where they reappear. He rejects the idea of “divine cartographies” that pretend people naturally belong in neat, homogeneous homelands, because real identities are far more mixed.
Arguments for partition include: that it’s historically inevitable or already happening; that it’s a last resort to avoid genocide or mass expulsion; that it reduces conflict better than keeping old borders; that it will lower current violence and create more stable, homogeneous states; and that heterogeneity causes problems, so homogeneous states should be the goal.
Arguments against
Arguments against partition include: that it destroys national territorial unity; that multi-national states aren’t necessarily bad; that no partition can be truly fair; that drawing new borders is extremely difficult; that it often leads to disorder and violence; that partition alone doesn’t create the desired homogeneity; and that new borders create new security problems. Daniel Posner notes that splitting diverse communities into supposedly homogeneous ones doesn’t fix communal conflict—it just changes people’s incentives and creates new divisions. For example, after India and Pakistan were divided along religious lines, the new religiously homogeneous states saw new social cleavages emerge on other grounds. Posner writes that relatively homogeneous countries can actually be more violent than countries with many evenly matched ethnic groups.
Examples of partitions include: the Roman Empire being split into Eastern and Western halves after the Crisis of the Third Century; Prussia divided by the Second Peace of Thorn in 1466 and later the Duchy of Prussia in 1525; Catalonia partitioned by the Treaty of the Pyrenees in 1659, giving Roussillon to France; a planned partition of Prussia in the Treaty of Versailles of 1757; the German occupation of Czechoslovakia, where the Sudetenland was ceded to Nazi Germany in 1938 and the country split into a German protectorate and a Slovak Republic, later reunified after World War II; three partitions of Luxembourg, the last in 1839, dividing it among France, Prussia, Belgium, and the independent Grand Duchy; three partitions of Poland in 1772, 1793, and 1795, which erased the Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth; the Treaty of Bucharest in 1913 partitioning Macedonia between Serbia, Greece, and Bulgaria; the partition of Tyrol by the London Pact of 1915; the partition of the German Empire in 1919 by the Treaty of Versailles; the partition of Prussia in 1919; the partition of the Ottoman Empire; the partition of the Austro-Hungarian Empire by the treaties of Saint-Germain-en-Laye and Trianon; and the partition of Ireland in 1920 into Northern Ireland and Southern Ireland, though this was only partially carried out.
Quick Facts
- Known for
- Division of territories along ethno-religious lines into separate nation-states
- Related concepts
- Secession
- ethnic separatism
- national self-determination
Facts from the source article.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Partition (politics)?
In international relations and political geography, partition describes the act of splitting a previously unified territory into two or more separate political units. It most often involves redrawing borders along ethno-religious lines so that distinct communities become their own nation-states.
How does partition differ from secession?
Secession is one group breaking away from a larger state, whereas partition reshapes borders on both sides of the divide, cutting through at least one territory that a community considers its homeland. Brendan O'Leary points out this key distinction: partition changes the political geography of multiple communities simultaneously rather than just one.
More in Legal Concepts & Doctrines
Sources
Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.
- Wikipedia: Partition (politics) (CC BY-SA 4.0).
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced