Jewish Nationalism Codexery

Jewish and democratic state

Last updated

"Jewish and democratic state" is the Israeli legal definition of the nature and character of the State of Israel. The "Jewish" nature was first defined within the Israeli Declaration of Independence in May 1948, while the "democratic" character was first officially added in an amendment to Israel's Basic Law: The Knesset passed in 1985. Numerous scholars and political observers have debated whether the terms are contradictory or complementary, particularly regarding the rights of Palestinians.

Quick Facts

First defined
May 1948 (Israeli Declaration of Independence)
Democratic character added
1985 (amendment 9, clause 7A of Basic Law: The Knesset)
Key judicial figure
Aharon Barak, President of the Supreme Court of Israel

Facts from the source article.

Background

The Israeli Declaration of Independence identifies Israel as a "Jewish state" in the sense that Jews, as an ethnicity, can exercise their right to self-determination in their homeland. The 2018 Nation-state law defined the right to self-determination as unique to the Jewish people in Israel and outlined roles and responsibilities for the state to serve as the Jews' nation-state. This law was met with sharp backlash internationally and characterized as racist and undemocratic by some critics; several Jewish diaspora groups expressed concern that it violated Israel's self-defined legal status as a "Jewish and democratic state" in favor of an exclusively Jewish identity.

The European Union stated the law complicated the Israeli–Palestinian peace process, while the Arab League, the Palestine Liberation Organization, the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, and the Muslim World League condemned it as a manifestation of apartheid. The word "Democratic" is absent from the Declaration of Independence, but the declaration states the intention to establish a state based on certain principles. Since no constitution had been passed by 1985, the Supreme Court ruled the Declaration a guiding principle.

During the 1984 Knesset elections, religious ideas aimed at replacing the democratic character with a theocratic Halachic state prompted the eleventh Knesset to pass an amendment to the Basic Law: the Knesset, effective from the Twelfth Knesset, stipulating the definition.

Public debate

In 1996, the National Democratic Assembly, a Palestinian party in Israel, raised the idea of Israel as a "state for all its citizens," stoking debates around the characterization of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state. As part of a project to draft a constitution by the Israel Democracy Institute (IDI) led by former Chief Justice Aharon Barak, the country's Jewish and democratic character was described as follows: Israel is a Jewish state in that it is the political framework for the right of the Jewish people to self-determination and a "Jewish nation-state," requiring a decisive Jewish majority.

This is conveyed through Zionism and Jewish heritage, including the right of every Jew to immigrate, Hebrew as the main official language, and a link to Jewish culture in public life, but it does not bestow extra privileges on Jewish citizens or impose religious requirements by state law. The state is democratic in that the sovereign is the entire community of citizens irrespective of ethnic-national origin, manifested by recognition of human dignity and the values of equality and tolerance, with arrangements for free elections, human rights, separation of powers, rule of law, and an independent judiciary.

The IDI concluded that the definition of Israel as a "Jewish state" does not contradict its definition as a "state of its citizens," as sovereignty lies in the community of citizens including the non-Jewish community.

Commentary by the Israeli High Court of Justice

The Fifteenth Knesset amended the Basic Law: The Knesset to enforce the limit not only upon a party or candidates list but also upon each individual separately. During elections for the 16th Knesset, the Israeli Central Elections Committee disqualified the candidacy of Azmi Bishara and Ahmad Tibi based on this law, while a petition to disqualify right-wing activist Baruch Marzel was rejected. Petitions were submitted to the High Court of Justice against all three rulings, and the High Court overturned the disqualifications of Bishara and Tibi while approving the rejection of Marzel's disqualification, allowing all three to participate.

Barak ruled that the minimal definition of "a Jewish State" and "a Democratic State" should be applied. He pondered whether every candidates list objecting to Israel as a Jewish and democratic state should be disqualified or a "Probabilistic standard" adopted, disqualifying only if there is a real chance of success in promoting contradictory goals, leaving that question open for future judicial debate.

More in Jewish Nationalism

Sources

Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.

Spotted an error? Know more?

Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced

Comments

Loading…
Open in the interactive codex →