Bench-clearing brawl
Mass player confrontation from benches in baseball and hockey.
A bench-clearing brawl happens when most or all players from both teams leave their dugouts, bullpens, or benches and rush onto the playing field, either to fight each other or to break up a fight. This type of brawl is most common in baseball and ice hockey. The penalties for leaving the bench can vary widely, from no punishment at all to severe sanctions.
In baseball, these brawls usually follow a series of escalating incidents or slights. A common trigger is when a batter gets hit by a pitch, especially if the batter then charges the pitcher's mound. Fights can also start from a confrontation between a baserunner and a fielder, such as overly aggressive contact during a tag play. Serious injuries are rare in these brawls; often no punches are thrown, and the action is mostly pushing and shoving. Notably, players from opposing bullpens will run onto the field together—sometimes side by side, depending on where the bullpens are located—to join the brawl, which is usually over by the time they arrive. This shows that the main purpose of coming onto the field is to show support for teammates, not to make the fight worse.
Unlike most team sports, where both sides have about the same number of players on the field, baseball puts the hitting team at a numerical disadvantage. The hitting team can have at most five players (the batter, up to three runners, and an on-deck batter) plus two base coaches, while the fielding team has nine players. Because of this, leaving the dugout to join a fight is generally seen as acceptable, since it makes the numbers more even, creates a fairer fight, and usually leads to a neutral outcome. In most cases, managers or umpires step in to restore order and restart the game. In at least one instance, the infamous Ten Cent Beer Night promotion, the home team (Cleveland Indians) left their dugout to defend the visiting team (Texas Rangers) from fans who had stormed the field.
Major League Baseball does not have a rule that automatically penalizes or ejects players who leave the bench or bullpen to join a fight. Instead, MLB penalizes fights as unsportsmanlike conduct. Because the hitting team can have as few as one offensive player against nine defensive players, the league is unlikely to change its rules to ban offensive players from joining brawls. Umpires have the discretion to eject participants in a brawl.
- Nhl first player penalty
- 10-game suspension and $10,000 fine
- Nhl subsequent players penalty
- 5-game suspension and $5,000 fine
- Iihf first player penalty
- double minor penalty plus game misconduct
- Iihf other players penalty
- misconduct penalty
- Khl brawl fines
- 5.6 million rubles ($191,000)
- Khl players ejected
- 33
- Nba penalty change year
- 1995
Lore & Background
In baseball, brawls are usually the result of escalating infractions or indignities, often stemming from a batter being hit by a pitch, especially if the batter then charges the mound. They may also be spurred by an altercation between a baserunner and fielder. Few bench-clearing brawls result in serious injury, as in most cases no punches are thrown and the action is limited to pushing and shoving. Players from opposing bullpens run onto the field, often side-by-side, to join the brawl, highlighting the purpose of showing support rather than escalating conflict. Unlike most team sports, in baseball the hitting team is at a numerical disadvantage, so leaving the dugout is generally considered acceptable to achieve numerical equivalence.
In ice hockey, fighting by enforcers is an established if unofficial part of the sport, especially in North America. Escalations beyond isolated fights, such as line brawls where most or all players on the ice begin to fight, are prohibited. Hockey brawls usually result from dangerous hits, excessive post-whistle roughness, taking shots after the whistle, attacking the goaltender, and hatred from competition. One notable incident was the Punch-up in Piestany during the 1987 World Junior Ice Hockey Championships, where a fight broke out causing both teams to leave the benches for 20 minutes; the game was declared void and both teams were ejected from the tournament. A notable KHL bench-clearing brawl saw all players except goaltenders begin fighting, resulting in 33 players ejected and the game counted as a 5–0 loss for both teams.
Reader's Guide
Bench-clearing brawls hold significant but varied roles across sports. In baseball, they are generally tolerated because the hitting team is outnumbered on the field, and leaving the dugout restores numerical balance, often resulting in a neutral outcome with managers or umpires restoring order. Major League Baseball does not have a rule specifying a mandatory penalty or ejection for leaving the bench, penalizing fights as unsportsmanlike conduct, and fines and suspensions are issued later. In ice hockey, the National Hockey League imposes automatic 10-game suspensions and $10,000 fines for the first player to leave the bench, with five-game suspensions and $5,000 fines for subsequent players. The International Ice Hockey Federation prescribes double minor plus game misconduct penalties for the first player leaving the bench. The legacy of these brawls includes severe consequences such as tournament ejections, as seen in the 1987 World Junior Championships, and massive fines in the KHL. Other sports have cracked down: the NBA changed its penalty in 1995 to an automatic one-game suspension, and the Northern Territory Football League in Australia ruled that any player leaving the interchange bench to participate in a melee would be ejected. Gridiron football penalizes substitutes leaving the team box with automatic ejection, and the amount of equipment greatly increases injury risk. Bench-clearing brawls remain notable for their rarity and the strong disciplinary responses they provoke.
Did You Know?
- In baseball, the hitting team is at a numerical disadvantage with a maximum of five players on the field compared to the fielding team's nine.
- The Punch-up in Piestany during the 1987 World Junior Ice Hockey Championships led to both Canada and the Soviet Union being ejected from the tournament.
- A KHL bench-clearing brawl resulted in 33 players ejected and fines totaling 5.6 million rubles ($191,000).
- The NBA changed its penalty for leaving the bench to participate in a brawl to an automatic one-game suspension in 1995.
More in Ice Hockey Terminology 1-24
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced