Historiography & Methods Codexery

Whig history

Historiography presenting history as inevitable progress toward a liberal present.

Whig history is an approach to historiography that presents history as a journey from an oppressive and benighted past to a glorious present, typically one characterized by liberal democracy and constitutional monarchy. Originally applied to British narratives praising the Westminster system, the term has been extended to other fields, such as the history of science, to describe teleological views of the historical process. It laid groundwork for modernization theory and post-World War II development aid, which has sometimes been criticized as destructive.

Quick Facts

Field
Historiography

Facts from the source article.

Terminology

The term "Whig history" was coined by British historian Herbert Butterfield in his 1931 book The Whig Interpretation of History, taking its name from the British Whigs, who advocated for parliamentary power against the Tories. Butterfield's usage did not refer to the Whig parties or Whiggism but criticized the 19th-century school of historiography that praised all progress and linked Protestantism with liberal views of liberty. The terms "whig" and "whiggish" have since become universal descriptors for all progressive narratives.

Earlier, in a 1928 Raleigh lecture, H. A. L. Fisher implied that whig historians were associated with the Whig party or its Liberal successor and wrote centrist histories that were "good history despite their enthusiasm for Gladstonian or Liberal Unionist causes"; his use was mostly approbatory, unlike Butterfield's later critique. P. B. M. Blaas argued in 1978 that whig history had lost all vitality by 1914, and subsequent academic historians have rejected it for its presentist and teleological assumptions.

Butterfield's purpose was to criticize oversimplified narratives that interpret past events in terms of the present for drama and moral clarity, noting that this approach leads historians to mistake the progressive sequence for a line of causation and to select only events that seem important from the present viewpoint.

British whig history

In Britain, whig history presents British history as a steady evolution of parliamentary institutions, benevolently watched over by Whig aristocrats, with steadily spreading social progress and prosperity. It describes a continuity of institutions and practices since Anglo-Saxon times that lent English history a special pedigree and instilled a distinctive temper in the English nation, issuing in law and legal precedent that preserved or extended English freedoms.

Paul Rapin de Thoyras's 1723 history of England became the classic Whig history for the first half of the 18th century, claiming that the English had preserved their ancient constitution against Stuart absolutism, though it was later supplanted by David Hume's history. According to Arthur Marwick, Henry Hallam was the first whig historian, publishing Constitutional History of England in 1827, which exaggerated the importance of parliaments and interpreted political struggles in terms of 19th-century Whig reformers versus Tory defenders.

Hume's History of England (1754–1761) challenged whig views, and whig historians attacked him but could not dent his history. In the early 19th century, some whig historians, members of the New Whigs around Charles James Fox and Lord Holland, incorporated Hume's views and needed a new historical philosophy. Fox intended to write a history of the Glorious Revolution but only managed the first year of James II's reign; a fragment was published in 1808. James Mackintosh then sought to write a Whig history of the Glorious Revolution, published in 1834.

Later instances and criticism

The history of science has been described as "riddled with Whiggish history," dividing historical actors into good guys on the side of truth and bad guys who opposed it due to ignorance or bias, with science emerging from victories over pre-scientific thinking. This whiggish tendency is commonly found in writings by scientists and general historians, while professional historians of science often oppose it. By the mid-1970s, historians of science routinely used terms like "Whig" and "Whiggish," often with "hagiographic," "internalist," "triumphalist," or "positivist," to denigrate grand narratives of scientific progress.

This paralleled earlier attacks on Whig constitutional history, which were part of a broader onslaught in the name of autonomous, professional, and scientific history against popular, partisan, and moralizing historiography. Post-World War II champions of professionalized history of science aimed to establish critical distance between the history of science and the teaching and promotion of the sciences, suspicious of the grand celebratory and didactic narratives that had proliferated in the inter-war years.

More recently, some scholars have argued that Whig history is essential to the history of science, noting that the very term "the history of science" has profoundly Whiggish implications, as the meaning of "science" changes over time—for example, chemistry was mixed with alchemy in the 17th century—and dissecting out "science" in the modern sense before that period involves profound distortions. The rejection of whiggishness by science historians has been criticized by some scientists for failing to appreciate the temporal depth of scientific research.

More in Historiography & Methods

Spotted an error? Know more?

Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced

Comments

Loading…
Open in the interactive codex →