The Incredible Mr. Limpet
A man becomes a fish to fight Nazis.
The Incredible Mr. Limpet is a 1964 American film that mixes live-action with animation, produced by Warner Bros. Pictures and adapted from Theodore Pratt's 1942 novel *Mr. Limpet*. The story centers on Henry Limpet, a timid bookkeeper who transforms into a talking fish and helps the U.S. Navy find and sink Nazi submarines. Don Knotts portrays the title character. Arthur Lubin directed the live-action portions, while Bill Tytla, Robert McKimson, Hawley Pratt, and Gerry Chiniquy handled the animation at Warner Bros. Cartoons. Sammy Fain and Harold Adamson wrote songs for the film, including "I Wish I Were a Fish," "Be Careful How You Wish," and "Deep Rapture." Critics gave the movie mixed reviews. It was the last project completed at Warner Bros. Cartoons before the studio shut down in May 1963.
The plot begins in 1963, with naval officer George Stickle and Admiral Harlock discussing unusual behavior in porpoises, suspecting that former secret asset Henry Limpet may be teaching them. A flashback to September 1941, before Pearl Harbor, shows Henry Limpet as a shy bookkeeper who loves fish and wishes to become one. His friend George Stickle serves as a machinist's mate in the Navy. Henry's wife Bessie is strongly patriotic, but when Henry tries to enlist, he is rejected as 4F due to poor eyesight and other issues. During George's leave, the trio visits Coney Island, where Henry falls into the water and inexplicably turns into a fish. Bessie and George assume he drowned.
As a fish, Henry keeps his pince-nez glasses and discovers a powerful underwater roar he calls his "thrum." He befriends Crusty, a grumpy hermit crab, and falls in love with a female fish he names Ladyfish, despite being married. After Pearl Harbor, Henry guides a Navy convoy to a German U-boat. He contacts the convoy and asks to see George, who helps Henry get commissioned by the Navy with an advanced rank and salary, which he sends to Bessie. Henry uses his thrum to locate Nazi submarines, aiding the Allied victory in the Battle of the Atlantic. In his final mission, the Nazis develop a thrum-seeking torpedo, and Henry loses his glasses. He survives by using Crusty as a navigator and redirects torpedoes to sink U-boats. After the battle, he swims to Coney Island to say goodbye to Bessie, who gives him new glasses, and then swims off with Ladyfish.
Quick Facts
- Director
- Arthur Lubin
- Producer
- John C. Rose
- Screenplay
- Joe DiMona / Jameson Brewer / John C. Rose
- Based On
- Mr Limpet / 1942 novel · Theodore Pratt
- Starring
- Don Knotts / Carole Cook / Jack Weston
- Music
- Frank Perkins
- Cinematography
- Harold E. Stine
- Editing
- Donald Tait
- Studio
- Warner Bros. Pictures
- Released
- 28 March 1964
- Runtime
- 99 minutes
- Country
- United States
Facts from the source article.
Lore & Background
The film's story begins in 1963, with naval officers discussing porpoises exhibiting unusual traits, suspecting former asset Henry Limpet is involved. It flashes back to September 1941, where Henry Limpet, a bookkeeper passionate about fish, is rejected from military service due to poor eyesight. After falling into the water at Coney Island, he inexplicably transforms into a fish, complete with his pince-nez spectacles. He develops a powerful underwater roar called his 'thrum,' befriends a hermit crab named Crusty, and falls in love with a female fish he names Ladyfish. Following the attack on Pearl Harbor, Limpet helps the Navy locate German U-boats, gets commissioned, and sends his salary to his wife Bessie. In his final mission, he survives a Nazi 'thrum'-seeking torpedo with Crusty's help, then swims to Coney Island to say goodbye to Bessie, who gives him replacement glasses, before swimming off with Ladyfish. The coda returns to 1963, where George and an admiral seek Limpet about training porpoises.
Reader's Guide
The Incredible Mr. Limpet received mixed reviews upon release, with a 40% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 10 reviews. The Los Angeles Times noted it would induce 'many laughs' and 'a tear or two,' while Diabolique magazine called it 'overlong and clearly budget-challenged but full of charm' and reminiscent of the Francis movies. Don Knotts, in his first lead film role, called it 'very very good.' The film was the last project finished at Warner Bros. Cartoons before its temporary closure in spring 1963, and one of the few non-Looney Tunes productions they worked on. A live-action remake was attempted multiple times from 1996 onward, with Jim Carrey, Mike Judge, Kevin Lima, and Richard Linklater attached at various points, but none materialized. The film was released on VHS in 1990, DVD in 2002, and Blu-ray in 2012.
Did You Know?
- The film was the final project produced at Warner Bros. Cartoons before its closure in May 1963.
- Don Knotts and Elizabeth MacRae (voice of Ladyfish) both worked on Andy Griffith's Mayberry franchises.
- The destroyer USS Alfred A. Cunningham and cruiser USS Galveston (portraying USS Los Angeles) were used in filming.
- The film premiered at the Weeki Wachee Springs Underwater Theater in Spring Hill, Florida.
More in Films About Wish Fulfillment 1-24
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced
