Proportionality (law)
General legal principle balancing measures against aims.
Last updated
R222mmllo1 · CC BY-SA 4.0
Proportionality is a general legal principle that appears in several distinct areas of law, including constitutional interpretation, criminal punishment, and armed conflict.[1] The concept requires balancing competing interests, such as the restriction imposed by a measure against the severity of the prohibited act.[1] In international humanitarian law, proportionality prohibits attacks where incidental civilian harm would be excessive relative to the anticipated military advantage.[2]
Quick Facts
- Field
- Law
- Known for
- General principle of law balancing restriction and severity
- Origin
- German administrative courts, late 19th century
- Key court
- Federal Constitutional Court of Germany
Facts from the source article.
Key facts and history
A testable legal concept of proportionality was first developed in German administrative courts in the late 19th century, notably by the Prussian Oberverwaltungsgericht.[3] In European Union law, a proportionality test generally has four stages: legitimate aim, suitability, necessity, and reasonableness.[4] The European Court of Human Rights uses proportionality as a main principle for scrutinizing national actions that restrict Convention rights.[5] The Federal Constitutional Court of Germany, in its jurisprudence, assumed the existence of a proportionality test and extended its use to constitutional law, thereby increasing its popularity.[3]
Statutes that limit fundamental rights, along with actions based on those statutes, were required by the German Federal Constitutional Court in a 1954 ruling to meet the proportionality test.[6] In Australia, the proportionality test is used for constitutional interpretation concerning legislative power under the Constitution.[7] Kirby J observed that the proportionality test 'has not enjoyed universal favour'.[7] Owen Dixon CJ stated that the issue is one of connexion, not the appropriateness of proportionality.[7]
During the 1980s, the U.S. Supreme Court put forward the Proportionality Doctrine in three cases, including Enmund v. Arizona (1987), under the Eighth Amendment's Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause.[8] The core idea is that the severity of punishment should correspond to the severity of the crime.[8]
What the cited sources add
The court must resolve any doubt about whether costs were reasonably and proportionately incurred in favour of the paying party.[9] In U.S. federal civil procedure, discovery scope is limited to matters that are "proportional to the needs of the case," considering factors like the importance of the issues and the burden or expense.[10] According to the Practical Guide to Humanitarian Law, lawful reprisals require a prior attack, proportionality to that attack, and targeting only combatants and military objectives.[11]
References
- Wikipedia, "Proportionality (law)" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Ministry of Justice, Part 44: General Rules about Costs, rule 44.4, accessed 14 November 2022. (we also read that source) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Proportionality (law)" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Article 51(5) of the Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions. "Treaties, States parties, and Commentaries - States Parties - Protocol Additional to the (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Proportionality (law)" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: L. Hirschberg (1978/79), <i>Der Grundsatz der Verhältnismäßigkeit</i> [<i>The Principle of Proportionality</i>] (Göttingen: Schwartz, 1981), , at p. 6 – cited i (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Proportionality (law)" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: P. Craig and G. de Burca, EU Law (5th edn OUP 2011) 526. (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Proportionality (law)" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: Dolzhikov, "The European Court of Human Rights on the Principle of Proportionality in 'Russian' Cases", 9 December 2011 (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Proportionality (law)" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: , referring to German Federal Constitutional Court (1954) E 3, 383, at p. 399 – available via {{lang|de|Das Fallrecht}}/University of Berne. (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Proportionality (law)" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: .; .; {{cite AustLII|HCA|30|1952|litigants=Burton v Honan |parallelcite=(1952) 86 169 |courtname=auto}}. (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, "Proportionality (law)" (CC BY-SA 4.0), which cites: "FindLaw Cases and Codes", Caselaw.lp.findlaw.com (original not read by us) en.wikipedia.org
- Ministry of Justice, Part 44: General Rules about Costs, rule 44.4, accessed 14 November 2022.. facts only, no text reused. justice.gov.uk
- "Rule 26. Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery Federal Rules of Civil Procedure LII / Legal Information Institute", Law.cornell.edu. facts only, no text reused. law.cornell.edu
- "Doctors without borders The Practical Guide to Humanitarian Law", guide-humanitarian-law.org. facts only, no text reused. guide-humanitarian-law.org
Each numbered sentence above was checked against the source it cites before publication. Sentences citing Wikipedia adapt text from the English Wikipedia article Proportionality (law) (contributors), used under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is available under the same licence. Other sources were used for facts only; no text or images are copied from them.
Also in the Codexery
More in Constitutional And Rights Law
Sources
Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.
- Wikipedia: Proportionality (law) (CC BY-SA 4.0).
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced
