In the Best of Families (miniseries)
A custody battle triggers a murder spree across two states.
Last updated
In the Best of Families: Marriage, Pride & Madness is a two-part American television miniseries directed by Jeff Bleckner and written by Robert L. Freedman, based on Jerry Bledsoe's 1988 nonfiction book Bitter Blood. The true crime story stars Kelly McGillis and Harry Hamlin as a couple who commit a series of murders across North Carolina and Kentucky during a custody battle. The miniseries softened the original book's grisly ending, which had made networks apprehensive.
Plot
In 1970, Tom Leary, a dental student, brings his fiancée Susie Sharp Newsom, a pampered Southern belle from a prominent North Carolina family, to meet his parents in Louisville, Kentucky. Despite his mother Delores’s disapproval, they marry in a large ceremony in Winston-Salem. Years later, living in Albuquerque, New Mexico, with their two sons, John and Jimmy, the marriage falls apart because Susie dislikes the city and struggles with a tight budget.
She leaves Tom, taking the children back to her parents’ home in Winston-Salem. Tom starts a new relationship with a woman named Kathy. Bitter, Susie blocks Tom from seeing the boys, sparking a custody battle. The stress affects her health, and she sees her uncle, Fred Klenner, a quack doctor, who tells her she has multiple sclerosis.
She reconnects with her first cousin Fritz, a survivalist obsessed with guns who pretends to be a medical student and CIA agent. Fritz claims to have secret government information and convinces Susie that Tom is tied to the mafia. Susie trusts him, and they begin an incestuous relationship. After her parents find out, Susie and her sons move in with Fritz.
When Fred dies of a heart attack, authorities force Fritz to close his father’s medical practice. The court orders Susie to let Tom see the children, and she blames Delores for her troubles. In 1984, Delores and her daughter Janie are killed in their home. The investigation, led by Lt. Dan Donaldson, goes nowhere.
Months later, Tom fears Susie is mistreating the boys. He asks Susie’s parents to testify at the custody hearing, and they agree. Still posing as a CIA operative, Fritz recruits a gullible young man from Virginia named Ian Perkins to join him on secret missions. They drive to Winston-Salem, where Fritz murders Susie’s parents and grandmother.
Tom realizes Susie and Fritz are responsible and tells Lt. Donaldson. Police find Ian, who confesses everything. As officers close in, Susie and Fritz try to flee the state with her two sons. A car chase and shootout break out during their escape.
With no way out, a bomb hidden in Fritz’s car explodes, killing everyone inside. Tom is left devastated by the loss of his children.
Cast
Kelly McGillis plays Susie Sharp Newsom, Harry Hamlin plays Fritz Klenner, and Keith Carradine plays Tom Leary. The cast also includes Holland Taylor, Jayne Brook, Ken Jenkins, Elizabeth Wilson, Louise Latham, Wayne Tippit, Tom Aldredge, Anne Pitoniak, Marian Seldes, Nick Searcy, Tristan Tait, and Colleen Flynn. Eric Lloyd and Erik von Detten portray the younger and older versions of John; Courtland Mead and Ira David Wood IV portray the younger and older versions of Jimmy; and Evan Rachel Wood makes her television debut as the younger version of Susie.
Production
The miniseries "In the Best of Families" was adapted from Jerry Bledsoe's 1988 true crime book "Bitter Blood." The book details the case of Fritz Klenner, who allegedly had a romantic relationship with his first cousin Susie Newsom Lynch and then committed multiple murders in North Carolina and Kentucky during the 1980s, stemming from a custody dispute over her two children. Robert L. Freedman wrote the script, and Jeff Bleckner directed. CBS aired it, with production handled by Ambroco Media Group and Dan Wigutow Productions.
Dan Wigutow executive produced, and Bleckner also served as a producer. The crew included cinematographer Alan Caso, editors Alan Shefland and Charles Borstein, and composer Don Davis. CBS had previously turned another Bledsoe book, "Blood Games," into the 1992 TV movie "Honor Thy Mother." Bledsoe said networks were initially reluctant to adapt "Bitter Blood" because of its grim conclusion, in which the two Lynch children are killed. Wigutow wanted the adaptation to have a meaningful purpose beyond being a sensational news story.
Release and reception
Originally titled In the Best of Families: Marriage, Pride & Madness just before its release, the two-part miniseries aired on CBS on January 16 and January 18, 1994, both from 9:00 to 11:00 pm. It later came out on home video in Europe as Bitter Blood. The broadcast occurred during a national discussion about TV violence, with U.S. Attorney General Janet Reno urging networks to reduce on-screen brutality. In response, producer Hamlin said violent stories like this reflect and critique society, and claimed the production team was careful to avoid exploitation.
Part one drew 15.2 million households (16.1% of TV-owning homes) and averaged 21.3 million viewers, ranking 20th for the week of January 10–16. Part two increased slightly to 16.3 million households (17.3%) and 23.9 million viewers, placing 18th for the week of January 17–23. The Wall Street Journal’s Robert Goldberg harshly criticized the violence as gratuitous and shocking, attacking both the script and CBS for airing what he saw as the worst TV film of the season, epitomizing the violence politicians wanted to stop.
Tom Shales of The Washington Post panned the plot as dreary and sordid, arguing that being based on a true story does not justify four hours of television.
More in 1990s American Crime Drama Television Series
Sources
Compiled from Wikipedia and the sources listed below. Text from Wikipedia is available under CC BY-SA 4.0; this entry is adapted from it.
- Wikipedia: In the Best of Families (miniseries) (CC BY-SA 4.0).
Spotted an error? Know more?
Reader corrections go straight into our review queue. Suggest an edit · How this site is sourced
